American Executives in Limbo at Chinese Chip Companies After U.S.
Ban
At
least 43 senior executives working with 16 listed Chinese semiconductor
companies hold roles from CEO to vice president
American workers hold
key positions throughout China’s domestic chip industry, helping manufacturers
develop new chips to catch up with foreign rivals. Now, those workers are in
limbo under new U.S.
export control rules that prohibit U.S. citizens from supporting
China’s advanced chip development.
At least 43 senior
executives working with 16 publicly listed Chinese semiconductor companies are
American citizens, according to an examination of company filings and official
websites by The Wall Street Journal. Many of them hold C-suite titles, from
chief executive to vice president and chairman.
Almost all of the
executives moved to China’s chip industry after spending years working in
Silicon Valley for U.S. chip makers or semiconductor equipment firms, according
to the companies’ filings. Their work histories reflect the free flow of talent
across companies and borders over the years. Some were drawn to China through
initiatives including the country’s “Thousand Talents” program, which was
introduced in 2008 by the Chinese government to boost research standards.
U.S. firms are
reshoring at the fastest pace in history, in part, due to the trade war with
China and rising tariffs. But that may not translate into a big win for
blue-collar American workers. WSJ’s Dion Rabouin
explains. Illustration: David Fang
The Commerce
Department this month imposed
export controls over an array of chips and chip-making
technology, marking the
U.S.’s biggest salvo against China’s tech industry so far.
In a rare move that
caught the industry off guard, it also sought to restrict the use of American
know-how by barring U.S. persons from supporting China’s advanced chip
development or production without a license. The department defines U.S.
persons to include U.S. citizens, permanent residents, people who live in the
U.S., and American companies.
Several companies,
including Beijing-based Naura Technology Group Co.
002371 8.06%▲ and
Dutch equipment maker ASML Holding NV, have suspended their American employees
from continuing work that could now be restricted while they seek clarity on the
rules, the companies have said.
Restricting Chinese
companies’ access to U.S. talent delivers a direct blow to the heart of China’s
attempt to move up the technology chain, said Dane Chamorro, a Washington,
D.C.-based head of global risk and intelligence at business consulting firm
Control Risks.
“The technology is
nothing without the people there to make it work,” he said.
For many senior
executives at Chinese companies, the rule will likely force them to decide
between their jobs and their U.S. citizenship or permanent resident status, Mr.
Chamorro said. The rules require all U.S. persons to apply for a license to
continue working in Chinese advanced chip development.
Among prominent U.S.
executives in China is Gerald Yin, founder and chairman of Advanced
Micro-Fabrication Equipment Inc., or AMEC, one of China’s largest
chip-making equipment vendors. He and six current senior managers and core
researchers at AMEC are American citizens, according to the company’s website
and its latest annual report.
Mr. Yin, whose
company is listed on the Shanghai Stock Exchange, spent almost 20 years working
at Silicon Valley companies including Intel Corp. and Applied Materials Inc., where he was
chief technology officer of its Asian unit before he left to found AMEC.
The Shanghai-based
company, which makes etching machines key to turning silicon wafers into
semiconductors, is viewed as a rising national champion in the sector, though
it still lags behind global leaders such as Lam Research Corp. and Applied
Materials. In its latest annual report, the company said it received more than
$50 million in subsidies from the Chinese government in 2021.
AMEC and Mr. Yin
didn’t respond to requests for comment.
Other companies that
face being affected include Chinese flash memory chip designer GigaDevice Semiconductor
Inc., an up-and-coming designer of flash chips used in automobiles and personal
computers. GigaDevice’s deputy chairman, Shu
Qingming, and a director, Cheng Taiyi, hold U.S.
passports, the company’s latest annual report says.
GigaDevice
didn’t respond to requests for comment.
KingSemi
Co., 688037 10.93%▲
which produces the most advanced coating and development equipment in China and
supplies giants including Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing
Co., TSM -4.05%▼
told investors that it is assessing
the impact of the new directives. An executive director, Chen
Xinglong, holds a U.S. green card, the company’s latest annual report says.
While the withholding
of talent—along with all the other restrictions—could significantly slow the
Chinese chip sector’s advancement, it won’t be enough to kill it, said Anne Hoecker, a partner at management consulting firm Bain &
Co. in its semiconductor group.
“There’s one thing
China has been very consistent about—their need to build up an indigenous
source of semiconductors,” she said. “They will continue to put a lot of money
in it, and they will continue to progress.”
Many companies,
including KLA
Corp. and Lam Research, have
already suspended the work of engineers and other less-senior
staffers in China while they seek clarity on the rules, or licenses to continue
their work, The Wall Street Journal previously reported.
Naura
Technology Group, which has a unit making semiconductor equipment, issued
warnings to its American employees within mainland China to suspend work with
clients that it believes fall under the new restrictions while it awaits more
clarity, a spokesman said. Those employees have continued to perform other
tasks at the company, he said.
ASML, the Dutch chip
equipment maker, confirmed it sent an internal email to its U.S. employees on
Wednesday, asking U.S. staff—both U.S. citizens and foreign nationals living in
America—to refrain from servicing, shipping or providing support to any of its
customers in China until further notice.
The new rules also
could affect employees of Chinese companies that have operations in the U.S.
Yangtze Memory Technologies Co., China’s leading memory chip maker, maintains a
Santa Clara, Calif., office, with more than a dozen employees in the U.S.,
according to LinkedIn. They include a director of engineering, the head of U.S.
NAND design, and the head of North American sales.