Netherlands
and Japan Join U.S. in Curbing Chip Technology Sent to China
A
new agreement is expected to expand the reach of U.S. technology restrictions
on China issued last year.
The Netherlands and Japan,
both makers of some of the world’s most advanced equipment for manufacturing
semiconductors, agreed on Friday to join with the United States in barring some
shipments of their most high-tech machinery to China, people
familiar with the agreement said.
The agreement, which
followed high-level meetings with U.S. national security officials in
Washington, will help expand the reach of sweeping restrictions issued unilaterally
by the Biden administration in October on the kinds of
semiconductor technology that can be shared with China.
The countries did not
publicly announce the agreement, because of its sensitivity, and details remain
unclear. But the deal seems likely to put technology industries in the
countries on a more even footing, preventing companies in Japan and the
Netherlands from rushing in to claim market share in China that has been
abandoned by U.S. firms. American companies have said that possibility would
put them at a disadvantage.
The White House and the
Dutch government declined to comment. The Japanese government did not
immediately respond to a request for comment.
The United States imposed
strict controls in October on the sale to China of both semiconductors and the
machines used to make them, arguing that Beijing could use the technology for
military purposes, like breaking American codes or guiding hypersonic missiles.
But well before those restrictions were issued, the United States had been
pressing the Netherlands and Japan to further limit the advanced technology
they export to China.
The October rules also
clamped down on certain shipments to China from countries outside the United
States. Using a novel regulation called the foreign direct product rule, the
Biden administration barred companies that use American technology, software or
inputs from selling certain advanced semiconductors to China. But these
measures applied only to chips, not the machinery used to make them.
Instead, the White House
continued to press allies to pass restrictions limiting the sales of
semiconductor manufacturing equipment by firms like the Dutch company ASML or
Tokyo Electron in Japan. The White House argued that the sale of this advanced
machinery to China created the danger that Beijing could one day make its own
versions of the advanced products it could no longer buy from the United
States.
The negotiations, which are
likely to continue, have had to overcome both commercial and logistical
concerns. Like the Americans, the Dutch and Japanese were concerned that if
they pulled out of the Chinese market, foreign competitors would take their
place, said Emily Benson, a senior fellow at the Center
for Strategic and International Studies, a Washington think tank. Over time,
that “could impact their ability to maintain a technological edge over
competitors,” she said.
The Dutch government has
already forbidden sales of its most advanced semiconductor machinery, called
extreme ultraviolet lithography systems, to China. But the United States has
encouraged the Dutch to also limit a slightly less advanced system, called deep
ultraviolet lithography. The deal reached Friday includes at least some
restrictions on that equipment, according to one person familiar with its
terms.
Governments have also faced
questions about whether they possess the legal authority to issue restrictions
like the United States, as well as extensive technical discussions about which
technologies to restrict. Japan and the Netherlands will still likely require
some time to make changes to their laws and regulations to put new restrictions
in place, Ms. Benson added, and it could take months or years for restrictions
in the three countries to mirror one another.