America
says Existing WTO Rules Unable to Address $1tn Unsustainable Trade Deficit with
China
[ABS News Service/07.11.2026]
Geneva – The United States said
it remains concerned about what it considers to be an unsustainable bilateral
trade relationship with China, echoing Washington’s desire to reduce the likely
huge trade deficit of $1 trillion a year while alleging that Beijing does not
play by the rules, during discussions on the World Trade Organization’s reform
track on level-playing-field issues, WTD has learned.
US trade envoy, Ambassador Joseph
Barloon, delivered a lengthy statement suggesting
that the asymmetry in the bilateral trade relationship with China had become
too great to be addressed under existing WTO rules.
Washington also conveyed that the
principles of non-discrimination, including most-favored-nation
treatment, could not be applied in the face of continuing asymmetries,
according to a person who asked not to be quoted.
During the marathon meeting on
the WTO reform track on LPFIs yesterday, the United States, alongside the
farm-defensive Group of Ten countries, led by Norway, Japan and Switzerland,
among others, opposed calls by a majority of developing countries to include
agriculture in the
level-playing-field discussions.
Washington insisted that
agriculture should be discussed only in the Committee on Agriculture in Special
Session, and not under the LPFI track, according to people familiar with the
developments.
Agriculture
However, several countries,
particularly Brazil, issued a notice that there would be no reform package for
adoption at the WTO’s 15th Ministerial Conference without agriculture being
part of the LPFIs track.
New Zealand, meanwhile, signaled
that it is considering tabling a document on agriculture, according to people
familiar with the discussions.
At the meeting, several countries
supported China’s proposals on LPFIs. Beijing indicated that it was willing to
discuss several elements concerning industrial subsidies on the basis of facts
rather than labels.
China also opposed labels such as
“non-market economies”, while expressing its willingness to discuss different
measures and the impact of subsidies that could be updated within the Agreement
on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures, according to people who asked not to
be quoted.
China’s proposal for multilateral
discussions on industrial policy also gained traction at the meeting, with the
European Union indicating its approval, according to people familiar with the discussions.
While the United States and EU
referred to data provided by the Paris-based Organization for Economic
Cooperation and Development on subsidies and state-owned enterprises, China
stated categorically that it would accept the OECD’s work on state intervention
and subsidies, according to a person who asked not to be quoted.
Brazil also appears to have made
it clear that, alongside agriculture, reform of the dispute settlement system
must be an integral part of the level-playing-field discussions. This demand
was also echoed by members of the least-developed countries and the Africa,
Caribbean and Pacific Group, according to people familiar with the discussions.
Washington and several other
industrialized countries also appeared indifferent to calls by many Members to
include the restoration of the two-tier dispute settlement system in the LPFI
discussions, according to people familiar with the discussions.
ACP Group
ACP Group members called for
discussions on distortions and asymmetries in agriculture, fisheries subsidies
and industrial subsidies, while opposing punitive measures in the notifications
and compliance segment.
Ahead of the meeting, the
outgoing facilitator overseeing the WTO reform discussions on level-playing-field
issues, Ambassador Elmer Jose German Gonzalo Schialer
Salcedo of Peru, issued a room document Friday containing questions for
least-developed countries, the ACP Group, China and Paraguay.
In a sharply delineated response,
the ACP Group said that, while differences and disparities in institutional
capacity and legislative architecture shape their Members’ ability to compete,
it pressed for “a balanced coverage of all trade-distorting subsidies and
measures across agriculture, fisheries and industry.”
Lesotho, on behalf of the ACP
Group, called for examining longstanding asymmetries in agricultural support,
capacity-enhancing fisheries subsidies and barriers to value-added exports in
the respective WTO bodies, alongside concerns about industrial support, state-owned
enterprises and overcapacity.
The group underscored the need
for a common approach to examining individual concerns, suggesting that Members
should consider how particular measures had disturbed the playing field for them,
according to people familiar with the ACP statement.
Moreover, the ACP Group argued
that discussions on LPFIs should reflect developing Members’ need to
industrialize, diversify and add value, as well as the importance of “effective
special and differential treatment”, because development cuts across all reform
tracks.
Notifications
On notifications, where some
industrialized countries have proposed punitive measures, the ACP Group appears
to have called for simpler and better-coordinated notification formats, usable
digital tools, timelines consistent with applicable rules and predictable
technical assistance for developing countries facing capacity constraints.
On the widespread use of
unilateral measures, particularly by the United States over the past one and a
half years, the ACP Group said such measures must be preceded by timely
information about their likely impact on developing countries, according to
people familiar with the discussions.
The ACP Group called for “a
Member-driven mapping of concrete concerns, the relevant WTO provision,
available evidence, development effects and the competent body to follow up,”
Lesotho is understood to have said on behalf of the group at the meeting.
It suggested that Members should
agree on the scope and sequence of this work while advancing outstanding
mandates in the relevant WTO bodies, Lesotho said.