Appeal Panel Upholds Consumer
Body 20 lakh Fine on Promoting Sale of Three Hazardous Chemicals, Erects
Barriers in Flow of Commerce Info through Online Channel
Ø
CCPA
Imposes Penalty of ₹20 Lakh on ExportersIndia.com (Weblink.In
Pvt. Ltd.) in Two Orders for Online Listing of Ammonium
Nitrate, PETN and Picric Acid
Ø Penalties and Directions Upheld; Appeals
Dismissed by NCDRC
·
The National
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC), through two orders dated 12 November 2026, dismissed
appeals filed by Weblink.In Private Limited, operator
of ExportersIndia.com, upholding CCPA's penalties and directions.
·
The Central
Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) had imposed a total penalty of ₹20 lakh (₹10 lakh under each
of two orders) for listing Ammonium Nitrate, PETN and Picric Acid
on the platform.
·
The CCPA's
final orders dated 8 September 2026 and 10 September 2026 directed the company to
permanently discontinue listing, hosting, advertising or facilitating the sale or
enquiry of these substances and other explosives.
·
The CCPA
held that displaying hazardous explosives as ordinary products with price quotations
and a "Get Best Quotes" option, without adequate legal warnings, amounted
to misleading advertisements
and unfair trade practices under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.
·
Key violations
included failure to verify sellers' valid PESO licences, buyers' identity and licensing
status, maintain traceability safeguards and display warnings about legal restrictions.
·
The company's
defence that it was merely a B2B directory and an intermediary protected under Section 79 of the Information Technology
Act, 2000, was rejected by both the CCPA and NCDRC.
·
The NCDRC
held that online platforms must exercise due diligence before listing regulated
and hazardous products and cannot claim intermediary immunity to avoid their consumer
protection obligations.
·
The CCPA
has also imposed a ₹10 lakh penalty on Dial4Trade, whose appeal was dismissed
by NCDRC on 9 October 2026. A similar ₹10 lakh penalty was imposed on Just
Dial.
·
Proceedings
against IndiaMART, Sigma-Aldrich, TradeIndia
and Ibuychemikals remain under investigation.
·
The CCPA
reiterated that e-commerce platforms must ensure strict compliance with applicable
laws before facilitating online trade in hazardous substances. Complaints regarding
online sale of explosives can be reported to the National Consumer Helpline (1915).
[ABS News Service/17.11.2026]
The National Consumer Disputes Redressal
Commission (NCDRC), New Delhi, through two orders dated 12 November 2026,
has dismissed the appeals filed by Weblink.In
Private Limited, operator of ExportersIndia.com, against two final orders of
the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA). The NCDRC has thereby upheld in
full the penalties and directions issued by the CCPA for the online listing,
hosting, advertising and facilitation of sale of regulated and hazardous explosive
substances on the platform. following the CCPA's earlier sector-wide action against
such listings on e-commerce platforms.
Background: CCPA's Action Against Online
Listing of Explosive Substances
The CCPA, headed by Chief Commissioner
Smt. Nidhi Khare and Commissioner Anupam Mishra, in
exercise of its powers under Sections 18 and 19 of the Consumer Protection Act,
2019, carried out a sector-wide review of e-commerce platforms to examine whether
hazardous chemicals, explosive substances and related precursors, namely Ammonium
Nitrate, Gun Powder, Picric Acid and Pentaerythritol Tetranitrate (PETN), were
being listed, hosted, advertised or made available for sale online.
These substances are regulated, restricted
or prohibited under the Explosives Act, 1884 and the rules framed under it.
Picric Acid stands declared an explosive by Notification GSR 625(E) dated 7 August
1983, while Ammonium Nitrate is regulated under the Ammonium Nitrate Rules, 2012.
The CCPA found that several platforms
were enabling access to these highly sensitive materials without disclosure of the
seller's valid PESO (Petroleum and Explosives Safety Organisation) licence,
verification of the identity and licensed status of the buyer, traceability safeguards
or caution regarding the legal restrictions on their possession and use.
The platforms examined included IndiaMART, Justdial, Dial4Trade, Sigma-Aldrich India,
ExportersIndia, Ibuychemikals
and TradeIndia. Following the CCPA's intervention,
the listings of these substances were delisted from the platforms.
Two CCPA Final Orders Against Weblink.In Private Limited
After issuing Show Cause Notices to the
company, calling for an investigation by the Director General (Investigation), sharing
the investigation reports with the company, considering its written replies and
hearing its counsel, the CCPA passed two separate final orders under Sections 20
and 21 read with Section 10 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019:
·
Final Order dated 08.09.2026: Relating to the listing of Ammonium Nitrate and PETN.
·
Final Order dated 10.09.2026: Relating to the listing of Picric Acid.
Both orders were challenged by the company
before the NCDRC.
Under each order, the CCPA imposed a penalty
of ₹10 lakh, taking the total penalty to ₹20 lakh. It
also directed the company to permanently discontinue the listing, hosting, advertising
or facilitation of sale of, or enquiry for, such substances and any other substance
classified as an explosive under the Explosives Act, 1884 or the Explosive Substances
Act, 1908.
CCPA's Findings: Misleading Advertisements
and Unfair Trade Practices
The CCPA held that the conduct amounted
to a misleading advertisement and an unfair trade practice under Sections
2(28) and 2(47) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and violated the right of
consumers under Section 2(9) to be protected against the marketing of goods hazardous
to life and property.
The platform displayed Ammonium Nitrate,
PETN and Picric Acid like ordinary products, with price quote options and an invitation
to "Get Best Quotes". However, it did not disclose that these substances
are notified explosives, that a licence is required to buy or sell them, or that
unauthorised possession is punishable. It also displayed a "verified"
tick against sellers of explosives, although the company admitted that it did not
check the licence of any seller or buyer. This gave buyers the false impression
that these substances could be freely and lawfully purchased.
The CCPA further observed that the platform
earned fees through paid memberships and a paid V-Trust Certificate, but failed
to put in place basic safeguards. The key deficiencies identified included:
·
Non-disclosure of sellers' PESO licences.
·
Failure to verify the identity and licensed status of buyers.
·
Absence of traceability safeguards as required under the Ammonium Nitrate Rules, 2012.
·
Failure to provide warnings regarding the legal restrictions on possession and use of these substances.
The company's claim that it was only a
B2B directory was not accepted, as anyone could register with just a phone number
and e-mail address and post a requirement for any quantity. Since explosives could
thereby reach persons with no legal right to hold them, the CCPA held that consumers
and the public were exposed to serious risk, in violation of Section 2(9). It also
held that the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 applied to the
platform.
Safe Harbour Defence Rejected by CCPA
and NCDRC
Before both forums, the company argued
that it was only an intermediary protected by Section 79 of the Information Technology
Act, 2000, that it had no actual knowledge of the listings and that no law required
it to verify licences of sellers or buyers of explosives.
The CCPA rejected these pleas. It held
that safe harbour under Section 79 is conditional on due diligence under Section
79(2)(c) and Rule 3(1)(b) of the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines
and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021. The "actual knowledge" standard
laid down in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India governs takedown of specific
content on notice, but does not remove the independent duty to exercise due diligence
at the point of listing. A compliance approach that only removes listings after
detection was held to be insufficient for regulated and hazardous substances.
The NCDRC affirmed this position. It held
that the platform could not plead selective diligence, that knowledge of the notifications
declaring these substances to be explosives could be ascribed to such facilitators
and that the company could not claim immunity under Section 79 of the IT Act.
The NCDRC also rejected the argument that
no statute required licence verification. It observed that a platform must take
reasonable care and exercise due diligence when its space is used to advertise trade
in hazardous substances, and that the advertisements carried none of the categorical
cautions that such substances demand.
The NCDRC found that the CCPA had acted
within its jurisdiction after following the principles of natural justice and that
there was no infirmity, perversity or error of law in its orders. In the
second appeal, it dismissed the challenge for the same reasons.
Action Against Other E-Commerce Platforms
The CCPA has also taken
action against other platforms examined during the sector-wide review:
·
Dial4Trade Technologies Private Limited: A penalty of ₹10 lakh was imposed
for listing Ammonium Nitrate. The NCDRC dismissed its appeal on 09.10.2026.
·
Just Dial Limited: A penalty of ₹10 lakh has likewise been imposed.
Proceedings against the remaining platforms
examined in this exercise, including India MART InterMESH
Limited, Sigma-Aldrich Chemicals Private Limited, TradeIndia
(Infocom Network Private Limited) and Ibuychemikals,
remain under investigation.
CCPA Reiterates Commitment to Consumer
Protection
The two NCDRC orders reaffirm that platforms
which host or promote listings of regulated and hazardous goods must exercise
due diligence before listing such products and cannot rely on intermediary status
to avoid responsibility under consumer protection law.
The CCPA reiterates its commitment to
protecting consumers and the public from the unregulated online availability of
hazardous substances and ensuring that e-commerce platforms comply with due-diligence
requirements.
Any instance of explosives being offered
for sale on an online platform may be reported to the National Consumer Helpline
at 1915.