Bessent Takes Tougher
Line on China, Deepening White House Rift Over AI Chip Exports
The Treasury secretary who sought to de-escalate tariff wars is taking a
tougher approach to exports of sensitive U.S. technology.
·
Bessent’s hawkish shift: Treasury Secretary
Scott Bessent, who previously worked to ease US-China tariff tensions, has adopted
a tougher position on exports of sensitive American technology, particularly advanced
AI chips.
·
Rivalry with Commerce Secretary: Bessent and
Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick are increasingly divided over China policy. Lutnick has favoured a more cautious
approach to restrictions that could affect Nvidia, while Bessent has pushed for
stronger controls.
·
Nvidia controversy: The dispute intensified following revelations
involving Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang and a woman associated with Singapore-based data
centre company Megaspeed, which
is under investigation over alleged smuggling of Nvidia chips to China. US intelligence
reportedly suspects the woman of links to Chinese intelligence. Megaspeed has denied
wrongdoing.
·
Bessent criticises Nvidia: Bessent has
questioned whether Nvidia's corporate culture encouraged allegedly illicit chip
sales to boost revenue and earnings. He has also publicly blamed the Commerce Department
for delays in taking action against Megaspeed.
·
Stronger export-control rules: On 16 November,
the Commerce Department issued a stricter rule targeting Chinese companies accessing
advanced AI chips remotely through data centres in Southeast
Asia. The stronger version was reportedly backed by the Treasury Department and
National Security Council, despite Lutnick's preference
for a softer approach.
·
Unusual public disagreement: The Commerce
Department's press release explicitly stated that the rule was written at the direction
of the Treasury Department and National Security Council. Former Commerce official
Christopher Padilla described this public distancing as unprecedented and a sign
of weakening coordination within the administration.
·
China's unmet commitments: Washington is
frustrated that Beijing has not fulfilled commitments to purchase American agricultural
products and accelerate exports of critical minerals essential for high-tech electronics
and military equipment.
·
Upcoming Trump-Xi discussions: The summit is
expected to focus on implementing the existing trade agreement, reducing tariffs
and trade barriers, and ensuring supplies of rare earth minerals. No major agreement
on nuclear non-proliferation is expected.
·
Bessent's stated objective: Despite his
tougher stance, Bessent says the US wants to “de-risk, not to decouple” from China. He is also working on an AI
alert system through which both countries could notify each other about serious
incidents involving AI models.
·
Trump remains non-committal: President Trump
has not publicly supported either side in the dispute. He acknowledged the competing
approaches—avoiding provocation of China versus taking stronger action—and said
he did not want to insult Beijing ahead of his meeting with Xi Jinping.
[ABS News Service/17.11.2026]
President Trump heads to Asia on Monday
(16.11.2026) for high-stakes meetings with foreign leaders aimed at ending Russia’s
war in Ukraine and smoothing over trade frictions with China. But the most tense meeting could take place aboard Air Force One.
Sequestered together on the journey
across the world will be Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
and Howard Lutnick, the commerce secretary, whose long-running
rivalry has recently spilled into the open.
Mr. Lutnick
is under fire for slow-walking several measures aimed at clamping down on the supply
of Nvidia chips to foreign data centers that serve Chinese clients. The controversy has put
Mr. Lutnick at odds with Mr. Bessent,
who has increasingly taken a hard line on China. While Mr. Lutnick
has pushed for policies more favorable to Nvidia, Mr.
Bessent has played the foil, going so far as to call for
a dramatic shake-up of the company’s leadership.
The Treasury secretary traditionally
manages America’s economic relationship with China. After spending much of last
year trying to de-escalate tension between the world’s two largest economies over
tariffs, Mr. Bessent has taken a more hawkish stance this
year amid growing concern over the artificial intelligence race with China and risks
that rogue Chinese A.I. technology could pose to the U.S. economy.
The internal clash over China policy
has echoes of Mr. Trump’s first term, when the president’s economic advisers regularly
argued about how forcefully to confront China over its trade practices. After Mr.
Trump imposed steep tariffs on Chinese imports last year, Mr. Bessent called for de-escalation and helped broker a trade truce
that stabilized the global economy.
But in recent months, the Trump administration
has been frustrated that China has not lived up to its commitments for purchases
of American farm products and to accelerate exports of its critical minerals, which
are needed for making high-tech electronics and military equipment.
In a call with Vice Premier He Lifeng of China this month, the Treasury Department said, Mr.
Bessent “raised concerns about recent Chinese actions”
related to the two nations’ agreement and that “continued progress depends on concrete
results.”
Michael Pillsbury, a China scholar
at the right-leaning Heritage Foundation who advised Mr. Trump during his first
term, said that Mr. Bessent’s hawkish turn when it comes
to technology exports is part of a broader acknowledgment that tariffs and sanctions
are not providing the United States with enough economic leverage when dealing with
China.
“It’s the realization that the original
plan or hope with China is not working,” Mr. Pillsbury said, adding that Mr. Bessent was being innovative in the “quest for leverage.”
This month, the divide over China
policy spilled into public view after Nvidia’s chief executive, Jensen Huang, was
revealed to be having an affair with a woman who led a Singaporean data center firm known as Megaspeed. U.S.
intelligence believes the woman is a Chinese intelligence asset. The company is
under
investigation for allegedly smuggling Nvidia chips to China.
Megaspeed said in a statement that it conducts legitimate and lawful business,
and designs its operations to comply with all laws.
When he was asked last week about
the U.S. government’s failure to sanction Megaspeed, Mr.
Bessent took the unusual step of declaring
that he and other officials had long been pushing for action
and placed blame on Mr. Lutnick.
“Commerce has the pen,” Mr. Bessent told CNBC. “You will have to ask them about their internal
processes.”
On Sunday, Mr. Bessent continued to exert pressure on Nvidia and called on
the company to explain itself.
“I want to keep coming back to, what
was the culture at Nvidia and were they pressing these seemingly illicit sales to
goose their revenues and their earnings?” Mr. Bessent
told Fox News.
In 2025, Mr. Lutnick
rolled out several aggressive measures on U.S. technology exports, which prompted
Beijing to take countermeasures that stopped the flow of critical minerals to the
United States. He has since taken a more cautious stance and warned that broad rules regulating overseas data centers could upset America’s relationship with China and other
countries.
On Monday, after months of fierce
internal debate, the Commerce Department issued a sweeping rule that will crack down on Chinese companies that have been remotely accessing
advanced A.I. chips through data centers in Southeast
Asia.
Mr. Lutnick
had proposed a softer version that would have had less impact on Nvidia, whose chips
are used in overseas data centers. But Mr. Bessent and others in the administration wanted a stronger provision
that would clamp down on Chinese access to A.I. computing power.
The Commerce Department, which has
authority over the topic, ultimately conceded and published a stronger rule on Monday.
But officials drafting the release made clear that it wasn’t their idea.
A news release issued by the Commerce
Department said that the new rule was “written by and at the direction of the Department
of Treasury and the National Security Council” — agencies that have both pushed
for more stringent rules.
Christopher Padilla, a former Commerce
Department official in the Bush administration, said he had never seen the agency
publicly disavow responsibility for a rule it was publishing and responsible for
enforcing. Only the Commerce Department has the technical expertise or legal authority
to write such a rule, he said, but the statement made clear that the agency did
not want to issue the rule and did so under duress.
It’s “like open mutiny,” Mr. Padilla
said. “That’s unprecedented, and publicly signals a breakdown of interagency cooperation.
Not a great signal to send anytime, but especially on the eve of a summit meeting.”
Officials have had limited expectations
for the China meetings, which are likely to touch on trade, nuclear weapons and
the war in Iran.
In a briefing call on Friday night,
administration officials said they did not expect to reach an agreement on nuclear
nonproliferation at the summit. They said that the focus
of meetings with Xi Jinping, the Chinese leader, and other Chinese officials would
be implementing a trade agreement between Washington and Beijing. That would include
reducing tariffs and other barriers to trade on each side, and ensuring that China
was supplying the United States with rare earth minerals.
In a speech at the National Committee
on U.S.-China Relations gala last week, Mr. Bessent said
that he was working with his Chinese counterparts to establish an alert system so
that the countries could notify each other of serious incidents involving A.I. models.
Despite his more hawkish tone, Mr. Bessent said that he
did not want to sever economic ties with China.
“As we work toward a more balanced
relationship, our objective is to de-risk, not to decouple,” Mr. Bessent said.
For now, Mr. Trump is not publicly
taking sides in the rivalry between Mr. Bessent and Mr.
Lutnick.
“One view is, you don’t want to insult
China,” Mr. Trump said on Monday as he departed for his trip. “The other view is,
just go down and dirty and do what you have to do. You can’t say either is wrong
or right.”
He added: “I don’t think you want
to insult China just before you get there.”