China Converts Oil
Vulnerability into a New Source of Geopolitical Power
The war with Iran revealed just how much
influence the world’s biggest oil importer has over prices and other countries’
supplies of jet fuel, gasoline and diesel.
·
Major strategic shift: The Iran
war has demonstrated that China has transformed its historic vulnerability to
oil-supply disruptions into a potential source of geopolitical leverage.
·
Energy-security build-up: China
has accumulated huge oil reserves, expanded refining capacity and invested
heavily in coal, renewables, batteries and electric vehicles (EVs).
·
23% reduction in oil imports: China
cut crude-oil purchases by 23% in the first six months of the Iran war
compared with the same period a year earlier.
·
Impact on global oil prices: Reduced
Chinese buying helped limit the rise in crude prices after disruptions to
shipping through the Strait of Hormuz. Goldman Sachs estimated that
crude was about $10/barrel lower by late August than it would have been
if China had maintained prewar purchasing levels.
·
Refined fuels as a geopolitical tool: China
sharply restricted exports of gasoline, diesel and jet fuel during the
early months of the war to conserve domestic supplies and exert pressure on
countries whose policies conflict with Beijing.
·
Selective fuel exports: Limited
exports reportedly went mainly to countries close to China, including Vietnam
and Thailand, while Australia and the Philippines received less
supply.
·
Possible renewed export restrictions: China
resumed wider fuel exports in July, but industry analysts warned that Beijing
could again restrict exports, particularly diesel, potentially putting further
upward pressure on global prices.
·
China's influence differs from OPEC: China is
a major oil importer rather than producer, but its enormous purchasing
power enables it to influence prices by changing the level of global demand.
·
Growing influence over oil markets: Analysts
cited in the report say China has not replaced OPEC, but its ability to
alter crude demand makes Beijing an increasingly important factor for oil
producers.
·
EVs reducing oil demand: EVs
account for around 14% of passenger vehicles on China's roads. The
International Energy Agency estimates that EV adoption reduced Chinese oil
consumption by about 1.5 million barrels per day in Q2.
·
Oil demand may have peaked: Sinopec
has indicated that China's oil consumption may have peaked in 2025,
earlier than previously expected.
·
Alternative transport and energy: China's
extensive high-speed rail network and ability to use coal instead of
oil in chemical production further reduce its petroleum dependence.
·
Strategic reserves: China
became a net oil importer in 1993 and subsequently accelerated the
creation of government oil reserves and diversification of energy supplies.
·
Malacca Strait vulnerability: China's
energy-security strategy was partly driven by concern that foreign navies,
including those of the United States or India, could disrupt Middle
Eastern oil shipments through the Strait of Malacca.
·
Huge stockpiles: Under President Xi Jinping,
China has continued expanding its oil reserves, which the report estimates at
roughly one-third of known global oil inventories.
·
Geopolitical implications: Former
U.S. officials cited in the report believe reduced oil vulnerability could
affect Beijing's calculations regarding potential actions involving Taiwan,
although China's dependence on imported crude remains significant.
·
Two-way energy leverage: China
can influence the market by reducing or increasing crude purchases and
by restricting or expanding exports of refined fuels.
·
Current market question: With
global crude around $103/barrel, markets are watching how much oil China
buys in coming months and how much crude it converts into diesel, gasoline and
jet fuel for export.
·
Key risk: A renewed Chinese restriction on
refined-fuel exports, particularly diesel, could further tighten global
fuel markets.
·
Overall significance: The Iran
war has highlighted China's emergence as a major energy-market power through
demand management, strategic reserves, refining capacity and energy
diversification, adding a new dimension to the traditional producer-driven
influence of countries such as Saudi Arabia.
One
of the most important lessons from the war with Iran is one that few saw coming.
The
conflict has made clear that China, which has long been highly vulnerable to oil
supply shocks, has managed to transform that weakness into a surprising source of
geopolitical power. The country made that big shift by stockpiling huge amounts
of oil, building extra oil refining capacity and investing in coal and other alternatives.
And in the early months of the war, it flexed that power by cutting off supplies
of jet fuel, gasoline and diesel to neighboring countries.
That
has big implications for the global energy industry, where oil producers like Saudi
Arabia and the United States — not importers like China — have traditionally held
most of the cards.
Already
dominant in solar panels, batteries and electric vehicles, China now appears to
have an unparalleled position across the energy landscape. As a result, the threat
that a foreign power would restrict the country’s access to oil may no longer deter
leaders in Beijing from taking aggressive steps like invading or blockading Taiwan,
former U.S. officials said.
“If
they come to feel that in this domain, they are less vulnerable than they and many
others may have assessed previously, that is a profound and important shift in one
of the key inputs to how China makes decisions about its global strategy,” said
Julian Gewirtz, a former White House and State Department official who worked on
China issues in the Biden administration.
China’s
massive oil reserves and refining capacity, paired with its ability to run its economy
on a variety of energy sources, allowed the country to slash oil purchases by 23
percent in the first six months of the war with Iran compared with the same period
the year before, customs data show. Other countries that rely heavily on crude oil
from the Middle East didn’t have those options and were forced to use less energy
or pay much more for it.
China’s
ability to throttle oil imports caught nearly everyone in the oil industry by surprise.
And it’s a big reason crude oil prices have not risen nearly as much as most energy
executives and analysts thought they would once Iran severely restricted the passage
of ships through the Strait of Hormuz. As of late August, crude oil cost roughly
$10 a barrel less than it would have had China continued buying at prewar levels,
according to Daan Struyven, who leads oil research for
Goldman Sachs.
“This
is a power that nobody thought China had,” said Erica Downs, a senior research scholar
at Columbia University’s Center on Global Energy Policy.
“Going forward, it’s going to be really interesting to see: What does China do with
this newfound power?”
Next
week’s scheduled meeting between President Trump and China’s leader, Xi Jinping,
at the White House, may provide some clues.
China’s
actions, even in just the past few months, suggest it will not be shy about using
energy as a political tool. The country depends heavily on foreign crude oil, but
it is one of the world’s biggest oil refiners. And early in the Iran war, the country
ordered severe restrictions on exports of refined fuels like gasoline and diesel,
both to conserve domestic supplies and to punish countries at odds with China’s
foreign policy.
What
little China did export this spring, when supplies were especially tight, went mainly
to countries that maintain close ties to Beijing, like Vietnam and Thailand. Australia
and the Philippines, which have been at odds with China because of its territorial
claims in the South China Sea, were among those that lost out. Such actions echo
the restrictions that China has placed on exporting rare-earth metals used in magnets
and computer chips.
China
resumed wider exports of jet fuel, gasoline and diesel in early July. But the last
shipments of Iranian oil, sent before the United States imposed a blockade, now
seem to have arrived at small refineries in China that operate separately from state-owned
giants, said Tom Reed, a longtime specialist in China’s oil industry at Argus Media,
a commodity pricing firm in London. He warned that China might reimpose a ban on
fuel exports soon. Taking yet another source of diesel off the market could cause
a further jump in prices, which are at a record of $6.40 a gallon in the United
States.
China’s
sway over the crude oil market is different from that of oil-producing countries
because China imports more than it produces. The country tends to reduce oil price
volatility, lifting prices when it is stocking up — as it was last year — and easing
them when it is not, as has happened since the war started, Goldman Sachs analysts
wrote recently.
China
is uniquely influential because it is such a big buyer and its autocratic government
exerts the kind of control that policymakers in democratic countries lack. The extent
of Beijing’s sway is becoming clear as fractures develop in the Organization of
the Petroleum Exporting Countries, an oil producers’ cartel that has long been the
most powerful force in the oil market.
“Have
they fully wrested control? No,” Dr. Downs said of China. “But are they a force
for OPEC to reckon with? Yes.”
China’s
steep drop in oil imports this year reflects two main changes. The country is no
longer stockpiling oil and has begun using some reserves. And its refineries have
cut back sharply on turning oil into gasoline, diesel and other fuels.
That
is partly because Chinese demand for oil has weakened so much that consumption most
likely peaked last year, ahead of forecasts, Sinopec, the country’s biggest refiner,
has said. Electric vehicles now make up around 14 percent of the passenger cars
on the road in China, a large enough share that the country used 1.5 million barrels
a day less oil in the second quarter than it would have with only gasoline or diesel
cars, trucks and buses, according to the International Energy Agency. That shaved
more than 1 percent off global oil demand.
China
also has a robust high-speed rail system and the ability, not widely shared by other
countries, to use coal, rather than oil, to make chemicals.
The
precise mix of tools China has used to reduce oil imports has been the subject of
intense debate because Beijing discloses very little. “I try to follow every little
piece of data, and all of it is conflicting and all of it is maddening,” said Rory
Johnston, an oil market researcher.
China
recognized the value of establishing government oil reserves relatively late, after
becoming a net oil importer in 1993. The United States and others set up large reserves
after the energy crises of the 1970s.
China
caught up quickly, however.
“Every
effort must be made to conserve and substitute oil, accelerate the exploration and
development of oil and natural gas, actively utilize overseas resources, and establish
a reserve system for oil,” China’s premier at the time, Zhu Rongji, told the country’s
legislature in 2001.
That
energy security strategy was motivated partly by fears that the U.S. or Indian navies
could block oil shipments from getting to China from the Middle East through the
Strait of Malacca, a small channel between Indonesia and Malaysia.
Mr.
Xi has maintained those priorities, overseeing the growth of stockpiles that now
represent roughly a third of known oil inventories worldwide.
Low
interest rates triggered by a severe housing market crisis since 2021 facilitated
the recent buying spree by Beijing and its state-backed oil companies. When interest
rates are high, the costs for buying and storing oil are steep. Unlike bonds or
dividend-paying stocks, oil does not generate income unless it is sold. But when
interest rates are very low, governments and companies see little difference between
holding cash and holding commodities like oil.
Among
the big questions now, with the main global oil price hovering around $103 a barrel,
is how much China will buy in the coming months, as well as how much of that crude
it will turn around and sell in the form of diesel and other fuels. Oil imports
climbed 6 percent in August from July but remained well below prewar levels.
“Think
about how much geopolitical influence Saudi Arabia has had over the decades because
of its ability to modulate production,” said Meghan O’Sullivan, a deputy national
security adviser for Iraq and Afghanistan under President George W. Bush. “If China
has that ability on the demand side, then they become an actor that the U.S. and
others will go to and ask them for that behavior in exchange
for potentially something else.”