Egypt Feels Pain of Global Disruptions Wrought by War and Pandemic
The
country’s economy has been very hard hit by cascading crises which have
disrupted worldwide trade.
When the state-owned factory
where Hesham el-Atar worked for 15 years was liquidated
this month, he had a feeling it was linked to international pressure on the Egyptian
government to reduce its role in the economy amid a severe downturn.
Mr. el-Atar, 39, was a supervisor at the factory, El Nasr Coke and
Chemicals Plant, which turned coal into a fuel called coke used in iron and steel
production. Now, with his daily expenses rising, he said that he fears he will not
be able to find another job near his home in the city of El Saf,
about two hours south of the Egyptian capital.
“I don’t know what to
do,” he said. “I have four kids. We’re used to a certain standard of living. It
will have to change.”
Egypt, which relies heavily
on imported goods and foreign borrowing, has been badly battered by the cascading disruptions
to global trade from the pandemic and Russia’s war on Ukraine. The
exit of foreign investment capital, a collapse in tourism and
spiking commodity prices have all translated into a foreign-currency shortage.
The government has responded
by implementing more onerous import rules, devaluing the local currency and pushing
up interest rates. It has also taken
steps to privatize or shut down state-owned enterprises, a key demand
of international investors and
creditors who say the government’s outsized role in the economy hinders
private investment.
But at the same time,
Egypt has succeeded in raising more than $22 billion this year in investment pledges
from wealthy Gulf allies leery of seeing one of the pillars of the Arab world on
the brink after a decade of tumult that began with the country’s 2011 uprising.
Consumers immediately
felt the impact of the government’s response to the crisis, particularly Egypt’s
middle class, which has been whittled away by a
persistent lack of job opportunities, decreases in consumer subsidies,
paltry spending on health and education and a regressive tax system that
goes in no small part to fund grandiose infrastructure projects.
The import rules introduced
at the beginning of the year required companies to pay for goods up front through
the national banking system. That left some imported goods stuck in the ports and
created shortages, though the government has since taken steps to ease the problems.
In March, the central
bank devalued the currency by about 14 percent and prices shot up. Salaries, however,
did not.
“We have to pay European
prices on Egyptian salaries,” said Mona Hosni, a 34-year-old Cairo resident. “Our
salaries are not like Europeans!”
Ms. Hosni works on one
side of Cairo and studies on the other. With the rise in prices, she cannot afford
to move out of her family home in the suburb of Helwan. So
she spends about three hours a day driving her 2011 Nissan between home, school
and work.
A new car is out of the
question.
The roads she drives on
are lined with new developments and billboards advertising luxury real estate, even
as much of the country remains mired in poverty.
In recent years, President
Abdel Fattah el-Sisi has overseen a huge building boom,
borrowing from abroad to fuel Cairo’s inexorable sprawl. The government is even
erecting a new capital in the desert, not far from the current one, at a cost of
some $59 billion.
Samer Atallah, an economics professor at the American University in
Cairo, said that the country had taken on tremendous debt — which is becoming more
expensive by the day as interest rates rise — without investing in the kinds of
things that could create more exports, more sustainable economic growth or steady
government revenues.
“Fundamentally, the economy
was geared up for a crisis,” he said.
The government has been
in talks with the International Monetary Fund about a loan: Economists estimate
that Egypt may need $15 billion over the next three years, though the
government has said it will seek a smaller package. And Egypt is
expected to devalue the currency even further soon.
The government must balance
the demands of investors — whose money could help alleviate the economic crisis
— with the risks of implementing measures that could cause even more economic pain
for its citizens.
International lenders
have urged Egypt to privatize more of its economy as one way to achieve more lasting
economic growth. Much of the economy has long been controlled by the state through
moribund government-owned companies.
In the case of the El
Nasr factory where Mr. el-Atar worked for 15 years, the
government said that it had incurred a loss of about $1.5 million
last year and had no possibility of modernizing or improving its financial standing.
The factory, which began production in 1964, was emitting significant pollution,
according to news
reports and government
documents.
Mr. el-Atar is now a union representative negotiating a severance
package for the workers but whatever deal is reached, the money surely won’t go
far given the rising prices and currency devaluation.
The military’s control
over a range of businesses has stifled competition from the private sector in industries
from concrete to pasta production by leaning on advantages such as free conscripted
labor and exemptions from taxes and customs fees.
Egypt has promised before
to privatize without following through. But as the economy cratered this year, the
government has shown signs of renewed resolve, starting to sell off or shut down
several state-owned companies.
Across Cairo, people from
all walks have been forced to adjust their daily routines to adapt to the economic
pressures.
At an auto-repair shop
in one suburb, two managers said that the cost of parts they need from Europe had
shot up and that they were losing customers because of the higher prices. Business
is half of what it was before the pandemic, they added.
“We’re all struggling,”
said Mostafa el-Gammal, the general manager. “It’s showing
on everyone.”
Though they haven’t laid
anyone off, wages at the shop are stagnant.
Mr. el-Gammal said that he tried to shield his four children from
the economic decline. But he said he was taken aback when he went to buy two of
them backpacks for the start of the school year and shelled out double what he had
in the past.
His colleague who manages
the auto shop, 33-year-old Mohamed Farouk, said that he had transferred his 6-year-old
son to a more affordable school near their home in Nasr City, another Cairo neighborhood.
The government has also
tried to increase revenue by raising fees for its services.
Assem Memon,
39, runs AdMazad, a private business with 14 employees
that collects data on billboards to sell to companies that want to optimize ad campaigns.
He said the economic slowdown and devaluation have complicated his plans to expand
outside Egypt.
The government was creating
headaches for employers, Mr. Memon said, including a new Ministry of Finance online
portal that must be used for all business-to-business transactions. The aim is to
allow the government to see every transaction.
Some tax withholding practices
were also changed, he added, reducing the cash he can keep on hand. While he understands
the government is aiming to increase revenue, he said the approach could deter entrepreneurship.
“It’s suffocating small
businesses,” he said.
Gamal Osman, 59, a warehouse
worker in Tanta, a city about two hours north of Cairo, said he was also paying
more in fees for basic services, like renewing his identification card. He said
that he had cut back to eating meat only once every two weeks and that, still, he
could not save money like he used to.
“You can feel it in everything
you do,” he said. “From the moment you step onto the street until the moment you
go to sleep.”
Still, others see opportunity
in the hardship.
Mohamed Ehab is a marketing
director for an auto company that introduced Jetour, a
Chinese brand, into the Egyptian market in 2020. Sales were booming last year, but
the new import rules have snarled the business.
The company stopped accepting
orders months ago and is focusing on expanding service centers.
Mr. Ehab said that there
was still demand for a practical family car, even after prices shot up with the
devaluation. The company’s lowest-priced car went up to $26,000 from about $18,000,
largely because the importers have to pay China in dollars.
But he is hopeful that
the impasse will spur the government to offer incentives for auto companies to assemble
their products inside Egypt, which could generate jobs and make cars more affordable.
“It’s a difficult time,
but I think it’s part of a bigger, good story,” he said.