Former Trade Officials
Reject Section 338, Investigation under Sec 301 the Way Forward
[ABS
News Service/18.11.2026]
Former senior US trade officials, legal
scholars and policy organizations have urged the Court of International Trade to
invalidate President Donald Trump’s 50 percent tariffs on some Canadian goods,
expanding the legal challenge to the Administration’s first use of Section 338
of the Tariff Act of 1930.
The amici filed their briefs last week
in the case Gellert Global Group Corp. v. Trump.
Gellert, a New Jersey food importer,
argues that the Administration exceeded its statutory authority and failed to
follow Section 338’s procedural requirements. The company seeks to halt tariff
collection and obtain refunds, with interest, for affected importers. Oral
argument is scheduled for January 20, 2027.
Former US Trade Representative Carla
Hills, former Deputy USTR Alan Wolff and former USTR General Counsel Warren
Maruyama contend that Congress effectively displaced Section 338 when it enacted Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974.
Section 301 established a more detailed
trade-enforcement system that includes investigations, public participation and
procedural safeguards.
The former officials argue that nine
successive Administrations treated Section 338 as a “dead letter” from 1975
until its invocation against Canada in 2026.
Their brief also asserts that the
Administration did not calculate the burden imposed on US commerce before
selecting the amount of Canadian trade subject to additional duties.
In their reading, Section 338 authorizes
tariffs only to “offset” a demonstrated burden or disadvantage, requiring a
relationship between the alleged injury and the responsive duties.
The brief further argues that Canada’s
dairy regime, although protectionist, does not constitute discrimination under
the statute because it does not disadvantage US products relative to like
products from every other foreign country.
Other briefs advance distinct statutory
theories. Former USTR Robert Zoellick and former State Department counselor Philip Zelikow argue that Section 338
historically applied to countries outside the United States’ reciprocal most-favored-nation system, not to treaty partners such as
Canada whose trade treatment is governed by congressionally approved
agreements.
The Cato Institute and George Mason
University law professor Ilya Somin filed a separate
brief arguing that the Administration’s interpretation conflicts with Section
338’s text, the major-questions doctrine and constitutional limits on
delegating legislative power.
They maintain that the statute requires
qualifying unequal treatment, a comparative finding of discrimination and an
offsetting – not merely punitive – response.
The Administration has said it will defend
the measures as a lawful response to what it characterizes as Canadian
discrimination against US automobile, alcohol and dairy exports.