Ivanka Trump Chooses Business
over Father
Donald J. Trump’s oldest daughter and former
top aide was once one of his most prominent campaign surrogates. Lately, she’s noticeably
absent.
[ABS News Service/30.10.2024]
Ivanka Trump has been surfing. She’s posed in front of the Eiffel
Tower, and attended a Formula 1 party in Miami in a race-car red dress. She took
a dip with her children in a hot tub, hung out with Kim Kardashian in Malibu, and
smiled alongside her husband, Jared Kushner, at the Acropolis.
The one place Ms. Trump hasn’t been, however, is the campaign trail.
And though she has been upfront about her absence, politically speaking, it remains
somewhat mysterious. During former President Donald J. Trump’s last two bids for
office, Ms. Trump appeared at rallies, in television ads and on national convention
stages, often with the implicit role of appealing to female voters.
But nearly two years ago, as her father started a third run for the
White House, Ms. Trump announced that she and Mr. Kushner would be stepping back
from politics to prioritize their children and family life.
“While I will always love and support my father, going forward I
will do so outside the political arena,” she said.
So it is in her father’s fiercest and
potentially final campaign that Ms. Trump — his oldest daughter, one of his former
top aides and perhaps his closest family member — has become a nearly silent observer,
with seemingly no intention of boosting his candidacy in any public way.
That decision to separate herself from her father’s politics comes
as Mr. Trump has faced the prospect of four separate criminal trials, including
one in her — and his — former home of Manhattan, where he was convicted of 34 felonies
in late May, and one in Washington, in connection with the Capitol riots of Jan.
6, 2021. One of Ms. Trump’s most prominent appearances during the 2024 race has
been at Mr. Trump’s civil fraud case last fall, when she testified that she wasn’t
“privy” to her father’s finances.
Ms. Trump, 42, declined to be interviewed, asking instead that Mr.
Kushner speak for her and her family. And when asked the chances that she might
rejoin the campaign fray in the final stretch of the race,
Mr. Kushner was blunt.
“Zero,” he said.
Mr. Kushner, 43, added that Ms. Trump “made the decision when she
left Washington that she was closing that chapter of her life. And she’s been remarkably
consistent.”
He went on to suggest that the outcome in the contest between Mr.
Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris may change little for their family.
While “obviously the world is different for us over the next four
years if her father is president,” Mr. Kushner said, he didn’t see “a major shift
in terms of what we prioritize.”
“We’re rooting for him — obviously, we’re proud of him,” he said.
“But, you know, either way, our life will just continue to move forward.”
Critics of the couple, however, said that even if Ms.
Trump remains outside of the government, Ms. Trump and her husband could stand to
benefit financially if her father is re-elected.
Mr. Kushner, who served as a senior adviser in the Trump
White House, now runs a $3 billion private equity fund bankrolled by the governments
of Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and Qatar, as well as by Terry Gou, the
Taiwanese billionaire and founder of Foxconn, the world’s largest electronics contract
manufacturer. It is an endeavor that has already earned
his firm at least $112 million in fees.
If Mr. Trump returns to the White House, there will be a steady stream
of questions about whether she and Mr. Kushner are getting special treatment in
any new deals they are making, particularly when the transactions directly involve
foreign governments, as is the case in several projects Mr. Kushner along with Ms.
Trump are already working on.
“He says it sort of self-effacingly, but at the end of the day, he’s
sitting there directing traffic all around the world,” said Vicky Ward, the author
of “Kushner Inc.,” about the couple’s various businesses, who suggested Mr. Kushner
could wield influence behind the scenes as a kind of “shadow secretary of state”
or “Kissinger 2.0.”
“They don’t need to go into government,” she said. “They’ve already
proven, in a way, that government is really good business for them.”
Ms. Trump’s low-to-no profile at other significant events in her
father’s life has also been conspicuous: Unlike her brothers Eric Trump and Donald
Trump Jr., she did not attend her father’s trial in Manhattan, where he was convicted
of 34 felony counts. And though she did briefly appear at the last night of the
Republican National Convention in July, she did not speak — a stark contrast with
the two previous conventions, when she introduced Mr. Trump.
Ms. Trump was also not in the audience this month at an all-female
town hall-style meeting held in Georgia and hosted by Fox News, nor was Melania
Trump, the former first lady, who has also largely kept her distance, save for rare
appearances, like at her husband’s rally at Madison Square Garden on Sunday.
In the past, the Trump women have tried to pitch Mr. Trump as a champion
for women and framed his presidency as uplifting for women in the work force, particularly
during moments when Mr. Trump’s comments and behavior
were under scrutiny.
Susan Del Percio, a Republican political
strategist, said it was unclear whether — after several political campaigns in which
Mr. Trump has alienated and insulted women — either his daughter or his wife could
be an effective surrogate in the race. Their absence, however, was telling, she
added.
“The positives that she could make on the trail is marginal, but
the fact that she and Melania are not on the trail could be significant,” Ms. Del
Percio said, noting that issues like reproductive rights
were motivating many voters.
Mr. Trump’s businesses — and political career — have always depended
on and heavily involved his family. And in place of Ms. Trump and the first lady,
Mr. Trump’s daughter-in-law, Lara Trump, has taken on a larger role, since he lobbied
to install her as the co-chair of the Republican National Committee in March.
Lara Trump appeared at a “Team Trump Women’s Tour” event on Thursday,
and has more scheduled in the final days of the race. Kimberly Guilfoyle, the fiancée
of Donald Trump Jr., has appeared at campaign stops and fund-raising events.
He’s also
occasionally been accompanied by more controversial female supporters, including
Laura Loomer, a right-wing conspiracy theorist who was
at the September debate with Mr. Trump, and Kristi Noem,
the South Dakota governor who boasted about killing a dog in her memoir released
in April, stood by the former president’s side during an awkward rally-turned-dance
party this month.
Ms. Trump’s name periodically crops up in Mr. Trump’s public appearances
and stump speeches, often in almost wistful ways. At a Moms
for Liberty event in August, Mr. Trump suggested he had once wanted to make her
the nation’s ambassador to the United Nations, but she had refused.
“She could have done anything,” the former president said. “Great
student, great beautiful girl, beautiful everything.” (When reached for comment,
Mr. Trump’s campaign directed a request for comment to Ms. Trump.)
Mr. Trump also mentioned his daughter in a segment at the women-focused
Fox News event this month, praising her support for a larger tax credit for children.
“You never heard of Ivanka, right?” Mr. Trump said, drawing a laugh
from the audience. “My daughter drove me crazy on this. We had the simplest, most
beautiful time.”
Ms. Trump’s withdrawal from her father’s side has been discreet.
She and Mr. Kushner left Washington, D.C., for the Miami area in 2021 with their
three children — a move that some interpreted as a kind of forced exile from New
York City, where they had lost the affection of former friends and acquaintances
because of their work in the Trump administration and in the wake of Jan. 6.
The family moved to an oceanside condo in Surfside, north of Miami
Beach, before buying a mansion in Indian Creek Village, a gated island community
in Biscayne Bay sometimes known as Florida’s “billionaire bunker.” The area consists
of only a few dozen homes, including those reportedly belonging to Tom Brady and
Jeff Bezos, and comes with its own private police force. Accessible only via boat
or a single, well-guarded bridge — and with a country club at its center — the village is perhaps Miami’s most exclusive location.
The move there, Mr. Kushner said, was a result of New York’s schools
being closed for Covid, adding that Miami is “a city on the rise,” and “it’s a lot
safer than being in New York right now.”
Observers say that Ms. Trump and Mr. Kushner — or “Javanka,” for short — have also flourished financially, freed
from governmental ethical rules.
“They’re much richer than they were before they went into government,”
Ms. Ward said. “And now he’s got a Rolodex of world leaders who are on the phone
to him. And when he puts the phone down, he can call his father-in-law.”
To be sure, some of Mr. Kushner’s deals have drawn intense scrutiny,
including a $2 billion investment in his equity fund from an investment fund controlled
by the Saudi government — known for its abysmal human rights record — shortly after
they left Washington. Plans for two high-end developments in Albania — one of which
Ms. Trump is helping to design — have also raised questions, with the couple facing
accusations of benefiting from a government looking to curry favor with the former, and perhaps future, president.
A representative for Mr. Kushner disputed trading on their influence
and connection with Mr. Trump to help their business interests, saying that he was
“proud of the many great relationships he has built over the course of his life
in both the private and public sectors.”
Ms. Trump’s New York roots were deep, having grown up in Trump Tower,
attended the Chapin School on the Upper East Side, and danced as a child ballerina
at Lincoln Center.
And from a young age she was entwined with her father’s ventures.
She worked for Mr. Trump after college and often guest starred on his reality television
show “The Apprentice” as she worked on building her own business selling clothes
and jewelry.
She hobnobbed with the likes of Chelsea Clinton and Rupert Murdoch,
hit the Met Gala more than once and, in 2009, married Mr. Kushner, whose purchase
of the money-losing The New York Observer had given him entree to the city’s media
elite.
Much of that social life was put on hold, however, after the couple’s
departure for Washington. In 2018, Ms. Trump shuttered her fashion business, after
being dropped by a number of major stores and after having been forced to step away
because of D.C.’s ethical rules, leaving the business — which she said was profitable
— in an untenable holding pattern.
“My focus for the foreseeable future will be the work I am doing
here in Washington,” she said at the time.
Now, Ms. Trump is self-employed, but is investing in businesses,
according to friends and advisers, though she hasn’t announced which ones. She also
volunteers, recently helping victims of Hurricane Helene with CityServe, a Christian-faith-based organization.
Her daily life sounds both commonplace and charmed: She cares for
her three children as well as her 98-year-old grandmother — Marie Zelníčková, the mother of Ivana Trump — who now lives with
the family on Indian Creek, along with two dogs and a hamster named Chester. She
practices jujitsu with the Valente Brothers (one of whom, Joaquim, is dating Mr.
Brady’s ex-wife, Gisele Bündchen) and qigong breathing;
she plays guitar, tennis and golf. She also meditates.
And complicating the notion that she’s been exiled, Ms. Trump has
also somewhat re-emerged in the social scene. She was spotted at Ms. Kardashian’s
birthday last fall in Beverly Hills, Calif., Art Basel in Miami Beach in December,
Mr. Bezos’s 60th birthday in Los Angeles in January and the extravagant Ambani wedding
in India over the summer. On occasion, Ms. Trump has popped up in New York, too,
including for a September party hosted by the designer Geraldine Guyot-Arnault, the wife of Alexandre Arnault,
an heir to the LVMH fortune.
Whether she will ever be fully accepted back into New York’s fashionable
circles is another question. Her brother-in-law Joshua Kushner, and his wife, the
model Karlie Kloss, have seemingly stepped in where Javanka
have left off, right down to purchasing their own struggling publication: Life magazine.
But Holly Peterson, a journalist and author who has long chronicled
the ways of the wealthy, said that Ms. Trump and Mr. Kushner’s place in New York’s
upper echelon was overstated to begin with.
“They were simply not part of New York society, ever,” Ms. Peterson
said, adding that the couple lacked the sense of civic duty that often accompanied New York’s prominent families. “Anyone will
tell you that Ivanka Trump — from school drop-off to fashion shows to galas to book
parties to cocktails in honor of someone who was launching
something — was never around. I never saw her in person.”
Ms. Trump’s friends counter that these days she is less concerned
with being seen, and more focused on quality of life, for her and her children:
Arabella, 13; Joseph, 11; and Theodore, 8. They attend a private Jewish day school
near their home; the family walks to synagogue for services on Saturday. (Ms. Trump
converted to Judaism before the couple married.)
“Miami really feels like home now,” said Julie Brawn, who has known
Ms. Trump for two decades and lives near the couple. “She’s super happy with the
lifestyle.”
Though Ms. Trump has largely avoided the spotlight over the last
couple of years, she made a recent exception for a podcast appearance. The host
of that podcast was Lex Fridman, an M.I.T. scientist whose
segments have recently featured polarizing, conservative figures like Elon Musk
and Vivek Ramaswamy, as well as Mr. Trump himself in September.
In a wide-ranging three-hour interview with Mr. Fridman in July, Ms. Trump touched on everything from architecture
to “The Apprentice,” with detours into Michael Jackson to Dolly Parton. (She said
Ms. Parton reminded her of her mother, Ivana, and leads with “a lot of love and
positivity.”)
She also reiterated that her decision to step away from politics
was a calculation involving what being away from her children could mean for them
emotionally. “I’m not willing to make them bear that cost,” she said.
She also, more pointedly, called politics
“a blood sport” and “one that you also can’t dabble in.”
Mr. Kushner said that he and Ms. Trump were
still close with Mr. Trump, speaking to him regularly by phone. During the summers,
they live side by side in Bedminster, N.J. They see each other less frequently during
winters in southern Florida, where they live about 60 miles apart.
“If he calls her for advice or help on something,
we’re always there,” Mr. Kushner said.
Depending on the result of the election next
month, that line to Mr. Trump could soon run straight to the White House, and the
couple’s distance from Washington may quickly evaporate once again. Still, asked
directly if the couple would ever re-enter the political sphere in a second Trump
administration, representatives for the pair pointed to Mr. Kushner’s comments and
to her interview with Mr. Fridman.
“I think you have to either be all in,” Ms.
Trump said in that interview. “Or all out.”