Japanese Bonds Up as Yields Rise as Japan Runs up
$9tn Debt
Trading of Japanese government bonds, long
considered moribund, is roaring back to life as fears of the country’s debt have
sent yields surging.
1. Two
Decades of Stagnation
·
Under the ultra-loose monetary policy of the Bank
of Japan, interest rates were kept near zero for years.
·
Yields on Japanese Government Bonds (JGBs) barely
moved.
·
Betting on rising yields became known as the “widow-maker”
trade because investors repeatedly lost money.
·
Trading volumes collapsed; some days saw no
benchmark bond trades.
2. Shock
Trigger: Fiscal Concerns
·
Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi
pledged tax cuts, raising concerns about Japan’s ability to manage its $9
trillion debt.
·
30-year bond yields surged sharply in a single
session.
·
40-year bond yields crossed 4% for the first time
since 2007.
3. Global
Market Impact
·
Volatility rattled global markets.
·
U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent contacted
Tokyo officials for reassurance.
·
Japanese yields influence global borrowing costs
and capital flows.
4. Debt
Trap Risk
·
Rising yields could increase Japan’s interest
burden.
·
Economists warn of a potential “debt trap”:
o
Higher yields → Higher interest payments
o
Higher payments → More borrowing
o
More borrowing → Further pressure on yields
5. Return
of Veteran Traders
·
After years of dormancy, experienced bond traders
are back in demand.
·
Hiroyuki Kubota described the market as a
“battlefield again.”
·
Global investment firms are recruiting seasoned
Japanese bond specialists.
6. The
1980s–90s Boom Era
·
In the bubble era, yields fluctuated dramatically.
·
10-year yields doubled from 4% (1989) to 8% (1990).
·
JGB futures became the world’s most traded bond
futures.
·
Nomura Securities played a key role in expanding
global participation.
·
Japan Exchange Group executives recall it as a
highly lucrative period.
7. The
Lost Years (1999–2023)
·
After the asset bubble burst and Asian financial
crisis, Japan entered prolonged stagnation.
·
In 1999, the Bank of Japan cut rates to zero.
·
By 2016, yields turned negative.
·
Trading desks shut down; talent exited firms like
Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley.
·
Recruitment firms described the shift as “juniorization.”
8.
Turning Point: Inflation and Policy Shift
·
In 2024, rising post-pandemic inflation pushed the
Bank of Japan to raise rates for the first time in 17 years.
·
Bond yields began rising again, ending two decades
of paralysis.
9. Hedge
Funds Reawaken
·
Kyle Bass of Hayman Capital long bet on rising
Japanese yields.
·
Previously dismissed, his thesis now appears more
plausible as Japan’s debt climbed to $8.77 trillion.
·
Hedge funds are increasing exposure and hiring
local expertise.
10.
Opportunity vs. Alarm
·
Some view rising yields as a warning of fiscal
strain.
·
Others see renewed volatility as a trading
opportunity.
·
Trading volumes in JGB futures have reached record
highs.
Conclusion
After two decades of dormancy under zero interest
rates, Japan’s government bond market has reawakened dramatically. Fiscal
concerns, rising inflation, and policy shifts have transformed JGBs from the
world’s “most boring market” into a high-stakes financial battlefield — signaling the return of active interest-rate dynamics in
one of the world’s largest debt markets.
For
two decades, few corners of global finance were lonelier than the market for Japanese
government bonds.
Under
the Bank of Japan’s longstanding regime of keeping borrowing costs pinned at zero,
yields on the securities, known as J.G.B.s, largely flatlined. Over the years, the
few contrarian investors willing to bet that yields might eventually rise were burned
so badly that the trade was named the “widow-maker.” In the world’s second-largest
government bond market, entire days would pass without a single benchmark bond changing
hands.
Those
days are gone.
Last
month, Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s vow to cut taxes sparked anxiety over Tokyo’s
ability to service its staggering $9 trillion debt. Yields on the 30-year government
bond surged more than a quarter percentage point in a single session, an enormous
move in a market where daily changes are typically measured only in hundredths of
a point.
The
volatility was so profound that Scott Bessent, the U.S. Treasury secretary, called
his counterparts in Tokyo seeking reassurances to help steady global markets rattled
by the moves. Yields, a benchmark for borrowing costs, jumped again last week after
Ms. Takaichi’s party won in a landslide election, which
investors viewed as a mandate for her high-spending agenda.
For
the broader Japanese economy, the spike signals a potentially grim slide. If yields
continue their ascent, some economists and investors warn that Japan risks falling
into a “debt trap” — a vicious cycle in which rising interest costs consume so much
of the national budget that the government must borrow even more just to pay the
interest.
But
for J.G.B.s and their veteran traders, the recent movements have generated a return
to a level of fervor not seen in decades. After a prolonged
professional hibernation, a rare class of traders and strategists — most now in
their 60s or older — are finding themselves back in the limelight as global investment
firms seek to tap their experience in navigating an environment of actual, moving
interest rates.
“It’s
becoming a ‘battlefield’ again,” said Hiroyuki Kubota, 67, who dealt Japanese government
bonds 40 years ago and has since written several books on the securities. “It’s
just like the old days.”
Mr.
Kubota began dealing the bonds in 1986, just after a series of reforms meaningfully
opened Japan’s government debt markets to global investors. At the time, Nomura
Securities, the king of Japan’s bubble-era finance, was hosting boozy, dayslong annual cherry blossom seminars in Kyoto to pitch government
bonds to overseas central bankers. The market was booming.
In
the 1980s and 1990s, yields shifted rapidly alongside fluctuations in Japan’s overall
economy. Yields on 10-year bonds doubled from 4 percent in 1989 to 8 percent in
1990, before falling back to 5 percent by 1992. Investors rushed to profit from
the swings. After J.G.B. futures — contracts to buy or sell bonds at a later date
— were introduced in 1985, they quickly became the world’s most heavily traded bond
futures.
“It
was a party,” said Hiromi Yamaji, 70, chief executive of the Japan Exchange Group,
recalling the annual Kyoto gatherings of the 1980s. Before assuming his current
post at the operator of the Tokyo Stock Exchange, Mr. Yamaji spent 36 years at Nomura.
J.G.B.s “were a very lucrative product,” he said. “Everybody was trading them a
lot.”
At
the time, traders were being wooed by the likes of Goldman Sachs and Salomon Brothers,
which were expanding their presence in Tokyo. Top-tier strategists could command
compensation packages in the millions of dollars as American firms sought to poach
talent from traditional Japanese banks.
Mr.
Kubota, the former J.G.B. dealer, started a website in the late 1990s featuring
a chat room that he said had attracted market movers and officials from Japan’s
Ministry of Finance. He hosted annual parties on a traditional Japanese houseboat,
where the elite of the bond world would talk shop while cruising the Sumida River
in central Tokyo.
Recent
swings in yields “may have been a shock to those who only knew the last 20 years,”
Mr. Kubota said. “But to those who know the old days, they aren’t strange at all.”
Paralysis
began to set in for Japanese government bonds around the turn of the century.
After
the bursting of the Japanese asset bubble and the 1997 Asian financial crisis, the
Bank of Japan in 1999 became the first major central bank in recent memory to lower
interest rates to zero. As the central bank began buying bonds to force rates down,
the 10-year yield hit a record low of less than 0.5 percent in 2003.
For
two decades, as policymakers kept rates near zero to combat persistent deflation,
yields hardly budged. In 2016, they fell below zero, meaning investors were basically
paying to hold the bonds.
“For
many, many years, it was a very difficult market,” the Japan Exchange Group’s Mr.
Yamaji said. “Nobody had any interest in trading.” With average daily trading volumes
tanking, Japan’s local banks, once the most aggressive traders of government bonds,
began to close their trading operations. International groups scaled back as well.
Many
veterans left high-paying foreign firms like Goldman Sachs or Morgan Stanley. They
either “semiretired” or were pushed into less glamorous roles, such as research,
at domestic firms, said Yoshiki Kumazawa, a director at Morgan McKinley, a recruitment
firm in Tokyo.
“We
call it ‘juniorization,’” said Mr. Kumazawa, who compared it to shipping a baseball player who
once starred for the New York Yankees off to a Japanese team.
Mr.
Yamaji tried to revive the market throughout the 2010s by introducing new trading
methods for the bonds, but the stagnation persisted until 2024. That was when a
burst of postpandemic inflation led the Bank of Japan
to raise interest rates for the first time in 17 years. This prompted a rise in
bond yields.
Those
yields then spiked higher on Jan. 19, when Ms. Takaichi
endorsed a tax-suspension measure estimated to cost more than $30 billion annually.
The next day, Japan’s 40-year bond yield broke above 4 percent for the first time
since 2007.
Some
see the surge as an alarming sign that Japan will struggle to finance its debt.
Kyle
Bass, founder of Hayman Capital Management, a Dallas-based hedge fund, was known
in the 2010s for his high-conviction bet that Japanese bond yields would eventually
skyrocket as the government’s debt load reached a breaking point, a wager widely
dismissed as the ultimate “widow-maker.” He acknowledges that the position did not
pay off at the time.
Now,
with yields rising and Japan’s total debt having risen to a record $8.77 trillion
last year, his thesis is becoming harder to dismiss.
“The
question is: How do they hold it all together?” Mr. Bass said. Borrowing costs are
rising in a number of the world’s largest economies. Japan, however, “is about 10
years ahead of everyone in its financial position,” he said. “I’m afraid of the
situation they’re in.”
For
others, the commotion is an opportunity. Average daily trading volumes of J.G.B.
futures have surged in recent years, and the number of outstanding positions in
the market has reached record highs, according to Mr. Yamaji. Global hedge funds
have snapped up top local talent, according to Mr. Kumazawa.
Mr.
Kubota, the former J.G.B. dealer and well-known bond watcher, said he was concerned
about the effect that rising yields would have on Japan’s national budget, but he
views the recent volatility more as a “canary in the coal mine” than the beginning
of a total crash. At the very least, his annual houseboat party will very likely
be injected with more energy, he said.
“It’s
feeling like it’ll be even more exciting this year than last,” Mr. Kubota said.
“It’s like it’s finally setting in that the era of moving interest rates has returned.”