Saudi
Arabia and Iran Agree to Restore Ties, in Talks Hosted by China
The
deal between regional rivals underlines China’s growing economic and political
importance in the Middle East, and what some analysts say is waning American influence.
After years of open
hostility and proxy conflicts across the Middle East, Saudi Arabia and Iran
have agreed to re-establish diplomatic ties, they announced on Friday, in a
significant pivot for the two regional rivals that was facilitated by China.
China hosted the talks that
led to the breakthrough, highlighting Beijing’s growing role as a global
economic and political power, and counterbalance to Washington — particularly
in the Middle East, a region that was long shaped by the military and diplomatic
involvement of the United States.
Seven years after cutting
formal ties, Iran and Saudi Arabia will reopen embassies in each other’s
countries within two months, and confirmed their “respect for the sovereignty
of states and non-interference in their internal affairs,” they said in a joint
statement published by the official Saudi Press Agency. Iran’s state
news media also announced the deal.
The two countries agreed to
reactivate a lapsed security cooperation pact — a shift that comes after years
of Iranian-backed militias in Yemen targeting Saudi Arabia with missile and
drone attacks — as well as older trade, investment and cultural accords.
Whether the shift leads to a
deep or lasting détente between governments that have long been in conflict
remains unclear, but there have been signs that both nations wanted to find a
way to step back from confrontation. Saudi and Iranian officials had engaged in
several rounds of talks over the past two years, including in Iraq and Oman,
but without significant steps forward.
For the United States, the
agreement signals that it cannot take for granted the pre-eminent influence it
once wielded in Saudi Arabia — an ally that is charting a more independent
diplomatic course — and elsewhere, as China, a rising superpower, builds trade
and diplomatic relations around the world.
While Washington views Iran
as an adversary, Beijing has cultivated close ties to both Iran and Saudi
Arabia, and unlike U.S. officials, it does not chastise them about human
rights. Iran’s president, Ebrahim Raisi, visited
Beijing last month, and China’s top leader, Xi Jinping, visited Riyadh, the
Saudi capital, in December. Mr. Xi’s state visit was celebrated by Saudi
officials, who often complain that their American allies are too critical, and
are no longer reliable security partners.
John Kirby, a spokesman for
the National Security Council, rejected the notion that the United States had
left a void in Middle East affairs, now being filled by China. “I would
stridently push back on this idea that we are stepping back in the Middle
East,” he said, adding that Saudi Arabia had kept the United States informed of
the talks with Iran.
“We support any effort there
to de-escalate tensions in the region,” Mr. Kirby said.
China’s most senior foreign
policy official, Wang Yi, indicated on Friday in a statement on the Chinese
foreign ministry website that Beijing had played an instrumental role in the resumption
of diplomatic ties.
“This is a victory for the
dialogue, a victory for peace, and is major positive news for the world which
is currently so turbulent and restive, and it sends a clear signal,” he said.
Mohammed Alyahya,
a Saudi fellow at the Belfer Center
for Science and International Affairs at Harvard, said the agreement was a
“reflection of China’s growing strategic clout in the region — the fact that it
has a lot of leverage over the Iranians, the fact it has very deep and
important economic relations with the Saudis.” He added: “There is a strategic
void in the region, and the Chinese seem to have figured out how to capitalize
on that.”
After years of tensions,
Saudi Arabia cut ties with Iran completely in 2016, when protesters stormed the
kingdom’s embassy in Tehran after Saudi Arabia’s execution of a prominent Saudi
Shiite cleric.
The rivalry between the two
Islamic nations, which are less than 150 miles away from each other across the
Persian Gulf, has long shaped politics and trade in the Middle East. It has a
sectarian dimension — Saudi Arabia’s monarchy and a majority of its populace
are Sunni, while Iran’s people are overwhelmingly Shiite — but has
predominantly played out via proxy conflicts in Yemen, Iraq and Lebanon, where
Iran has supported militias that Saudi officials say have destabilized the
region.
Tensions hit a peak in 2019,
when a missile and drone assault on a key Saudi oil installation briefly
disrupted half of the kingdom’s crude production; the Iran-backed Houthi
movement in Yemen claimed responsibility, but U.S. officials said that Iran had
directly overseen the attack.
In Yemen, a Saudi-led
coalition has been at war with the Houthis since 2015. Saudi officials have
also repeatedly expressed fear over Iran’s nuclear program, saying that they
would be the foremost target for any attack by the Islamic Republic.
China wants stability in the
region, with more than 40 percent of its crude oil imports coming from the
Gulf, said Jonathan Fulton, a nonresident senior
fellow for Middle East programs at the Atlantic Council.
“Beijing has adopted a smart
approach using its strategic partnership diplomacy, building diplomatic capital
on both sides of the Gulf,” he said. “Unlike the United States, which balances
one side against the other, and is therefore limited in its diplomatic
capacity.”
Ali Shamkhani, the head of
Iran’s Supreme National Security Council, told Iran’s NourNews
Agency that President Raisi’s visit to China in
February had helped create the opportunity for the negotiations to move
forward.
Mr. Shamkhani described the
talks as “unequivocal, transparent, comprehensive and constructive.” He said he
was looking forward to relations between Iran and Saudi Arabia that foster “the
security and stability of the region.”
For Iran, mending ties with
a regional enemy would be a welcome relief after months of internal turmoil
marked by antigovernment protests that Iranian officials
have blamed in part on Saudi Arabia. The Iranian government spokesman, Ali Bahadori Jahromi, tweeted that
“the historic agreement of Saudi-Iran negotiated in China and led entirely by
Asian countries will change the dynamics of the region.”
The Israeli foreign ministry
declined to immediately comment. But the news complicates the Israeli
assumption that shared fears of a nuclear Iran would help Israel forge a formal
relationship with Saudi Arabia. Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli prime minister,
has repeatedly stated in recent months that he hoped to seal diplomatic ties
between Israel and Saudi Arabia for the first time.
Saudi Arabia has pressed the
United States to lower restrictions on selling it arms, and to help it build a civilian nuclear
program, as its price to normalize relations with Israel,
according to people familiar with the exchanges.
The agreement comes as China
has been trying to play a more active role in global governance by releasing a
political settlement plan for the war in Ukraine and updating what it calls the
Global Security Initiative, a bid to supplant Washington’s dominant role in
addressing the world’s conflicts and crises.
Political analysts took
mixed views of the implications for the United States.
Mark Dubowitz, the chief
executive of the Foundation for Defense of
Democracies, a Washington-based research institute, described the renewed
Iran-Saudi ties resulting from Chinese mediation as “a lose,
lose, lose for American interests.”
He added: “It demonstrates
that the Saudis don’t trust Washington to have their back, that Iran sees an
opportunity to peel away American allies to end its international isolation and
that China is becoming the major-domo of Middle Eastern power politics.”
But Trita
Parsi, an executive vice president of the Quincy Institute, a Washington
research group that advocates U.S. restraint overseas, called the agreement
“good news for the Middle East, since Saudi-Iranian tensions have been a driver
of instability in the region.”
Saudi officials are not
looking to replace the United States with China, said Yasmine Farouk, a nonresident scholar at the Carnegie Endowment for
International Peace, a Washington research group.
When it comes to defense and security, “Riyadh still thinks in English,” she
said. But after years of feeling that the United States has become a less
reliable ally, the Saudis are expanding their alliances wherever they can.