The Dollar’s Weakness Creates an
Opportunity for the Euro which has Hit $1.13
European officials see the concern over
the “safe haven” reputation of U.S. financial assets as a chance to attract
investors.
·
Indication
that funds are flowing to Europe: Since the beginning of April, the euro has gained
5.4 percent against the dollar, rising above $1.13, the highest level since late
2021.
·
Beginning
of a long-term trend in which the euro firmly encroaches on the dollar’s role as
the world’s dominant currency.
·
Sovereign
debt crisis in 2012, followed by a decade of ultra low
interest rates, meant the region’s bonds offered low returns.
·
The
euro is now used by 20 member countries and represents about 20 percent of the world’s
central banks foreign exchange reserves, a figure that has barely budged in the
past two decades. Thirty percent of global exports are invoiced in euros, whereas
more than half are in dollars.
·
New
development is the prospect of Germany issuing about 1 trillion euros in additional
government debt, known as bunds and considered the safest euro-denominated assets.
·
The
yield on 10-year bunds was 2.47 percent, reversing nearly all the increase that
followed the stimulus announcement.
·
The
European Union issued more than 600 billion euros in bonds.
·
The
price of gold has soared, exceeding $3,300 per troy ounce, and the Swiss franc has
also surged, gaining nearly 7 percent against the dollar this month.
President
Trump’s shake-up of the global trade system has sent tremors through the long-held
view that the United States is the source of the world’s safest financial assets.
That’s created an opportunity for Europe.
The
market tumult in which investors simultaneously sold off the U.S. dollar, American
stocks and U.S. Treasury bonds eased last week as Mr. Trump backed off his threats
to fire the Federal Reserve chair, Jerome H. Powell, and Treasury Secretary Scott
Bessent tried to reassure foreign officials that trade
deals would be struck.
But
many European officials attending the spring meetings of the International Monetary
Fund and World Bank in Washington last week were skeptical
that the uncertainty over Mr. Trump’s trade policy would dissipate any time soon.
They said the unpredictable nature of the Trump administration’s approach to setting
policy would not easily be forgotten. Instead, they saw the potential to attract
investors to European assets, from the euro to the bond market.
“We
see that our stability, predictability and respect for the rule of law is already
proving a strength,” Valdis Dombrovskis, the European commissioner responsible for
the trade bloc’s economy, said on Wednesday in a discussion on the sidelines of the I.M.F. meetings. “We already have stronger
investor interest in euro-denominated assets.”
The
most comprehensive indication that funds are flowing to Europe: Since the beginning
of April, the euro has gained 5.4 percent against the dollar, rising above $1.13,
the highest level since late 2021.
The
question among policymakers and investors is whether the recent jump in the euro
and other euro-denominated assets is simply a short-term rebalancing of portfolios
that heavily favored the dollar or the beginning of a
long-term trend in which the euro firmly encroaches on the dollar’s role as the
world’s dominant currency.
A troubled past
“There’s
a lot of enthusiasm about Europe,” Kristin J. Forbes, an economist at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, said in an interview.
She
said the excitement about the euro reminded her of the currency’s founding in 1999,
when some economists and policymakers raised the prospect of it replacing the dollar.
In its early years, the euro’s international use exceeded the combined use of the
currencies it replaced.
But
then the euro was hit by crises. Despite having a monetary union of a dozen members,
including Germany, Europe’s largest economy, the region remained politically fragmented,
sapping confidence in the currency. The sovereign debt crisis in 2012, followed
by a decade of ultra low interest rates, meant the region’s
bonds offered low returns.
The
euro is now used by 20 member countries and represents about 20 percent of the world’s
central banks foreign exchange reserves, a figure that has barely budged in the
past two decades. Thirty percent of global exports are invoiced in euros, whereas
more than half are in dollars.
Speculation
about new dominant currencies should be taken “cautiously,” Ms. Forbes said, but
there is more momentum behind the euro.
“This
feels like it does have more legs because it is a combination of a stronger, more
unified Europe,” she said. “At the same time, there are more problems emerging with
U.S. dollar assets.”
Improvements
have been made on some of the issues that previously deterred foreign investors.
Today, European bonds are providing better returns, and investors trust that the
European Central Bank will be the lender of last resort, minimizing the risk that
one country’s economic troubles could affect all euro assets.
More safe assets
For
investors, the most promising new development is the prospect of Germany issuing
about 1 trillion euros in additional government debt, known as bunds and considered
the safest euro-denominated assets.
For
years, Germany’s strict fiscal conservatism has restrained the supply of bunds.
But last month, Parliament altered the borrowing limits anchored in its constitution,
the so-called debt brake, to allow the government to borrow hundreds of millions
of euros to invest in the military and infrastructure.
“There
are cheers in Europe” because of Germany’s fiscal stimulus, said Kristalina Georgieva,
the I.M.F. managing director. “And it adds something that is not tangible, but it
is important — confidence.”
The
demand for German debt has preceded any additional issuance. During the recent market
turmoil, bund prices rose, pushing down the yields, a clear sign of investor interest.
At the same time, yields on U.S. government bonds have moved in the other direction.
By the end of last week, the yield on 10-year bunds was 2.47 percent, reversing
nearly all the increase that followed the stimulus announcement.
Investors
are also anticipating an increase in debt issued jointly by European governments,
an idea that has been proposed to finance more military spending across the bloc.
Economists have pointed out that this happened before: The European Union issued
more than 600 billion euros in bonds to finance post-pandemic recovery programs.
But that borrowing faced fierce opposition, and future issuance would also struggle
to win the backing of all the member states.
Although
there has been confusion and frustration with the Mr. Trump’s trade policies, many
European officials, including central bankers, emphasized the need for Europe to
seize this moment.
“This
will be a time of creativity and pragmatism, getting things moving,” Olli Rehn,
the governor of the Finnish central bank, said in a speech. “I am very much looking
forward to this period as a positive challenge because we are very serious about
reinforcing common defense in Europe. Which will, by the
way, need safe assets.”
‘A long and hard road’
Optimism
is growing about the role of the euro. Klaas Knot, the
governor of the Dutch central bank, said he had gone from being agnostic about the
international use of the euro to a “cautious believer.”
But
he added that “the external strength” of the euro “is a reflection of internal strength”
in Europe, and governments need to go further to increase that strength, he said
in a speech on the sidelines of the meetings in Washington.
Officials
must continue to deepen the single market that connects the bloc’s more than 448
million people and enable them to trade and do businesses freely, Mr. Knot said.
Lawmakers, he said, also needed to build a single capital market that would make
it easier for money to cross European borders. “We still have quite some work to
do in Europe.”
Alfred
Kramer, the director of the I.M.F.’s European department, warned against “over-interpreting”
the recent shift toward the euro. A “move to European exceptionalism,” he said,
is “still a long and hard road away.”
The
region, he said, needed many more structural changes that would enable a more dynamic
business sector in which companies could reach larger markets and pools of capital.
Many
officials said it was more likely that the euro would be one of several assets that
become more prominent as investors reduce their holdings in dollars. In recent weeks,
for example, the price of gold has soared, exceeding $3,300 per troy ounce, and
the Swiss franc has also surged, gaining nearly 7 percent against the dollar this
month.
“I
don’t see everyone massively getting out of dollars and suddenly shifting to the
euro; I think it’s more a healthy diversification,” Ms. Forbes said. But private
investors abroad who have built up a lot of holdings in U.S. debt and are now watching
the dollar decline want alternatives.
“Europe,”
she added, “is a natural place to diversify.”