Trump Administration Divided Over
China’s AI Chip Policy Amid Nvidia Scandal
The airing of a fight
over advanced A.I. chips shows how much the Nvidia scandal has deepened fissures
inside the government, just as President Trump heads to a critical meeting with
his Chinese counterpart.
·
Policy
Differences: The Trump
administration is divided over how strictly to restrict China’s access to advanced
American AI chips, with Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
favouring tighter restrictions and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick advocating a more flexible approach.
·
Nvidia
Controversy: The controversy
intensified following Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation amid revelations about
his personal relationships and alleged links between Alice Huang and Chinese intelligence.
·
National
Security Concerns: US intelligence
officials, including Secretary of State Marco Rubio, had reportedly warned Trump
about potential Chinese espionage risks associated with the Nvidia controversy.
·
New Export
Restrictions: The US
Commerce Department has introduced new rules requiring foreign data centres to obtain
government licences before providing significant computing power to companies headquartered
in China, Russia, Iran and other high-risk countries.
·
Closing
the Loophole: The restrictions
aim to prevent Chinese companies from accessing advanced Nvidia chips indirectly
through overseas data centres and third-party companies.
·
Implementation
Challenge: The new
rules will take effect after 90 days, with the Commerce Department responsible for
enforcement despite Lutnick's reported opposition to the
restrictions.
·
Trump’s
Balancing Act: Trump
is attempting to balance national security concerns with protecting Nvidia's commercial
interests and avoiding another trade conflict with China ahead of his meeting with
President Xi Jinping.
·
Political
and Economic Differences:
Treasury, the State Department and National Security Council favour tougher controls,
while the Commerce Department has expressed concerns that excessive restrictions
could damage US-China trade relations.
·
Nvidia’s
Business Interests: Trump
has previously permitted Nvidia to resume certain chip exports to China in exchange
for a share of government revenue, reflecting the administration's interest in maintaining
the company's commercial growth.
·
Concerns
Over Policy Consistency: Former
National Security Adviser H.R. McMaster argued that Trump's preference for negotiating
major deals with China has contributed to frequent changes in US policy towards
Beijing.
[ABS News Service/17.11.2026]
President Trump headed on Monday
(16.11.2026) for a trip to Asia to meet President Xi Jinping of China with his administration
openly divided over how hard to squeeze that country on artificial intelligence
technology.
Mr. Trump noted before he left that
he has not wanted to make moves that “insult China.”
The public airing of the fight over
China policy inside Mr. Trump’s cabinet shows how much the fallout of the Nvidia
scandal has deepened fissures inside the government,
forcing into view a debate about how the United States should reckon with Beijing.
Mr. Trump, who is due to meet Mr.
Xi and President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia at a summit in the Chinese tech hub
of Shenzhen this week, has struggled to balance national security concerns about
America’s most powerful rival against his desire to prop up Nvidia’s chips business
and avoid another trade war with Mr. Xi.
Those tensions were center stage on Monday as the president acknowledged that Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick had been at odds
over how hard to crack down on a loophole that has allowed China to access advanced
A.I. chips through data centers in other countries.
“One wants to be friendly with China,
and one wants to have a blowup with China,” Mr. Trump
said of his two cabinet secretaries, speaking to reporters on the South Lawn before
leaving for Asia. “Both are acceptable, but they’re different views.”
The debate intensified with the resignation last week of Nvidia’s chief executive, Jensen Huang, after revelations
that he had two extramarital affairs, including with Alice Huang, a woman whom U.S. officials have identified as a Chinese intelligence
asset.
Amid the fallout, Mr. Trump has appeared
more concerned in public about offending Mr. Xi than about the risks to national
security. He has downplayed reports about the warnings he received from U.S. intelligence
officials and Secretary of State Marco Rubio personally about Mr. Huang’s relationship
and the spying by China.
Chinese officials have denied that
Ms. Huang is an intelligence operative. And on Monday, Mr. Trump again cast doubt
on it.
“I don’t know that she is a spy,”
he told reporters. “Usually, what happens with that is that any woman coming to
the country that’s a beautiful woman that comes from China, they say she’s a spy.”
A reporter noted that Mr. Rubio had warned him about Ms. Huang being a spy. “Who told me that?” the president asked.
Told that it was Mr. Rubio, he said:
“I haven’t heard that.”
When asked where the president stood
in the debate about how to approach China, a White House spokesman, Matthew Middleton,
touted the new rule the administration issued on Monday to close the loophole giving
China access to advanced American chips through third countries.
“This action will help ensure that
America’s most advanced chips go first to U.S. S.I. innovators, not Chinese shell
companies,” he said in a statement, a reference to Mr. Trump’s preferred term of
“super intelligence.”
“The Trump administration will continue
to take decisive action to protect America’s technological edge, strengthen our
national security and ensure the future of S.I. is built in America,” Mr. Middleton
added.
The divide over China policy inside
the Trump administration goes beyond the two feuding cabinet secretaries, according
to more than half a dozen current and former officials with direct knowledge of
the discussions. On one side of the fight is Mr. Lutnick,
whose department writes and enforces chip export rules and who pushed for a softer version of the restrictions on data centers. On the other side are Mr. Bessent;
Mr. Rubio, who is also Mr. Trump’s national security adviser; the U.S. trade representative,
Jamieson Greer; and much of the National Security Council staff. All of them have
pressed for months for broad limits on China’s access to A.I. chips.
The president has drifted between
the two camps in private, depending on the day, according to advisers.
In a Friday television interview,
Mr. Bessent faulted the Commerce Department for failing
to sanction Megaspeed, the Singaporean company at the
center of the Nvidia scandal, saying that the department
“has the pen.” He also said that Nvidia should be “held accountable” if it did not
do enough to stop the illegal diversion of chips to China.
On paper, Mr. Trump sided with his
Treasury secretary. Shortly before he left for Asia, his administration issued the restrictions on China’s chip access that Mr. Bessent
had pushed and that Mr. Lutnick had resisted.
But the president’s wavering comments
on Monday left some China hawks inside and outside the administration worried that
he might reverse himself or treat the new rule as a bargaining asset to trade with
Mr. Xi.
When reporters asked the president
about the delicate situation on Monday, he insisted that Mr. Lutnick was “doing a very good job.” He suggested that any delay
in acting against Megaspeed had been meant to avoid upsetting
Mr. Xi.
“If you didn’t delay it, if you didn’t
do something, you could have a blowup with China,” Mr.
Trump said. He added: “I don’t think you want to insult China just before you get
there.”
The new rule, issued by the Commerce
Department on Monday morning, will require data centers
outside the United States to get a government license before selling significant
computing power to firms with headquarters in China, Russia, Iran and a small group
of other high-risk countries. Officials say that will close a loophole that has
let Chinese firms rent the advanced Nvidia chips they are barred from buying, access
that has helped China’s A.I. industry advance rapidly. U.S. officials involved in
the debate have said that China’s A.I. models pose a major threat of cyberattacks
against the United States.
The news release announcing the move
carried an unusual line that reflected the fight behind it: The rule, the
Commerce Department said, had been “written by and at the direction of the Department
of Treasury and the National Security Council.”
The new policy takes effect in 90
days. Enforcing it will fall to Mr. Lutnick, a staunch
opponent of the measure. A person close to Mr. Lutnick
said he had repeatedly warned the president and his colleagues that the restrictions
could start another trade war with China. Another person close to Mr. Lutnick said the disclaimer about the Treasury Department and
the N.S.C. was meant to make clear who was responsible for what they view as a misguided
policy.
The Commerce Department did not immediately
respond to a request for comment.
Mr. Huang stepped down as Nvidia’s
chief executive last week under pressure from the company’s board, after revelations
about his relationships with a company executive and Ms. Huang, whom U.S. officials
have identified as an asset of China’s Ministry of State Security. Ms. Huang founded
Megaspeed, the Singapore-based data center company that U.S. authorities are investigating over
allegations of smuggling chips to China. (Megaspeed has
said that it operates a lawful and legitimate business.)
The Times has previously reported that Mr. Trump was warned at least twice about Mr. Huang’s relationship,
late last year and again in the spring. According to two U.S. officials briefed
on the matter, Mr. Rubio was so concerned about Mr. Huang’s entanglement with Ms.
Huang that he wrote a classified memo on March 30 summarizing intelligence that
showed she was in contact with China’s top spy agency. Then in May, aboard Air Force
One, Mr. Rubio briefed Mr. Trump on the intelligence in person, the officials said.
The secret intelligence about Ms.
Huang played a backstage role in shaping the president’s trip to Beijing in May,
the officials said. Mr. Huang was left off the initial list of executives invited.
But after news reports noted his absence, Mr. Trump called him, and Mr. Huang traveled to Anchorage to meet Air Force One at its scheduled
stopover. At the time, Mr. Trump called reports that Mr. Huang had not been invited
“FAKE NEWS!”
Mr. Trump has stood by Mr. Huang throughout
the saga. Last week, The Times has reported, the president called him and urged
him to fight for his job. On Monday, the president said he “would not mind” seeing Mr. Huang reinstated. “I think he learned
a big lesson,” Mr. Trump said.
Mr. Huang has cultivated the president
since the start of the second term, praising him lavishly in public and making announcements
of huge investments that Mr. Trump has touted as administration successes.
In August 2025, Mr. Trump allowed
Nvidia to resume exports of its H20 chips to China on condition of a 15 percent
cut for the government — though Beijing never approved the sales. Two months later,
Nvidia committed $25 million to Mr. Trump’s White House ballroom.
In December, Mr. Trump announced that
Nvidia could sell its more powerful H200 chips to China in exchange for 25 percent
of revenue flowing to the U.S. government. Mr. Trump has told aides he regards Nvidia
as central to the stock market and the broader economy.
The data center
rule had stalled within the administration for months. Mr. Trump approved it in
August, according to two senior officials, but the Commerce Department did not issue
it. The Biden administration had imposed similar restrictions just before leaving
office. The Trump administration rescinded them last year, and several drafts of
replacement rules have died since.
Current and former officials who support
a tougher stance against Beijing said they hoped that Mr. Trump’s words on Monday
were merely diplomatic niceties, and that he would follow through on the chip restrictions
and let the Megaspeed investigation run its course.
Others who have worked for the president
were more skeptical. Since Mr. Trump retreated from his
tariff war with Beijing in May 2025, he has made clear to his national security
team that he is wary of taking any actions that might disrupt the trading relationship.
H.R. McMaster, who served as Mr. Trump’s
national security adviser in 2017 and 2018 and whose memoir of that period gave
a nuanced assessment of what he felt the president did well and what he didn’t,
said Mr. Trump’s instinct for deal-making had repeatedly undercut his China policy.
“I think President Trump is often
impeded by his belief that he can get the deal nobody else can get,” Mr. McMaster
said. “And as a result, instead of having a consistent policy of competing against
China’s policy of economic aggression, he often vacillates and weakens his own position.”