US
Prosecutors Accuse Huawei of Trade Secret Theft, Bank Fraud and Sanctions
Evasion in Landmark Criminal Trial
Chinese tech giant accused of doing
whatever it took to grow and protect its business, ‘including committing crimes
after crimes’
·
Closing Arguments: US
prosecutors delivered approximately six hours of closing arguments on Monday in
the high-profile criminal trial of China's Huawei Technologies before a federal
court in Brooklyn, New York. The case has been ongoing for nearly eight years.
·
Charges: Huawei and three affiliated
companies face 12 remaining criminal counts, including:
o
Racketeering conspiracy.
o
Conspiracy to steal trade secrets.
o
Bank fraud and wire fraud.
o
Obstruction of justice.
·
Prosecution's Allegations:
Assistant US Attorney Meredith Arfa accused Huawei of
a long-running pattern of criminal conduct, describing its activities as
involving "thefts, lies and
cover-ups". Prosecutors alleged that Huawei systematically stole
competitors' confidential technology to increase profits and protect its market
position.
·
Trade Secret Theft:
o
T-Mobile's Tappy Robot:
Prosecutors alleged that a Huawei employee stole part of T-Mobile's
smartphone-testing robot, known as Tappy, and
subsequently lied about the incident.
o
Cisco: Huawei was also accused of
stealing Cisco's source code.
o
Corporate Culture:
Prosecutors cited a 2013 internal memo offering bonuses to employees who
obtained competitors' confidential information.
·
Obstruction of Justice:
Prosecutors alleged that Huawei attempted to obstruct the investigation by
moving employees out of the United States and misleading the media and US
Congress.
·
Iran Sanctions Evasion:
o
Huawei allegedly used Hong Kong-registered Skycom as a concealed subsidiary to conduct business in
Iran and circumvent US sanctions.
o
The company allegedly misled banks, including HSBC,
about its relationship with Skycom.
o
US dollar transactions linked to Iranian operations
were allegedly routed through the American financial system.
o
Prosecutors also alleged that Skycom
assisted Iran in domestic surveillance activities.
·
Meng Wanzhou's Admission: A key
piece of evidence was a 2021 deferred prosecution agreement involving Huawei
CFO Meng Wanzhou, daughter of founder Ren Zhengfei. She acknowledged misleading HSBC about Huawei's
relationship with Skycom, presenting it as an
independent third party despite knowing that Huawei controlled the company.
·
Huawei's Defence: Huawei
has denied all wrongdoing. Its defence argued that the company's success
resulted from decades of research and development rather than theft of trade
secrets or sanctions violations. Defence closing arguments are expected on
Tuesday.
·
China's Reaction: Beijing
has criticised the prosecution, describing the case as an example of US
bullying of Chinese companies.
·
Trial Proceedings:
o
Trial commenced in September.
o
Prosecution presented 61 witnesses over nearly
seven weeks.
o
Jury deliberations could begin on Wednesday and
continue until a verdict is reached.
o
Meng Wanzhou is not a
defendant in the current trial; charges against her were subsequently
dismissed.
·
Potential Penalties: If
convicted, Huawei could face substantial criminal fines and forfeiture of proceeds
from the alleged offences, potentially resulting in one of the largest
corporate penalties in US history.
·
Huawei's Business Scale:
o
Founded in 1987 and headquartered in Shenzhen,
China.
o
World's largest telecommunications equipment
manufacturer.
o
2025 revenue: US$126 billion.
o
Global workforce: approximately 213,000
employees.
o
Research and development workforce: approximately 114,000
employees.
Significance: The
verdict could have major implications for Huawei's global operations and
US-China technology relations, particularly concerning intellectual property
protection, financial institutions' sanctions compliance and the accountability
of multinational corporations.
US
prosecutors spent about six hours on Monday delivering their closing arguments
in the criminal trial of Huawei Technologies at a packed federal court in New
York. The case – one of the most high-profile legal battles involving a Chinese
technology giant – has dragged on for almost eight years.
Huawei
and three affiliated companies face 12 remaining criminal counts, including
racketeering conspiracy, which prosecutors allege involved the companies
reinvesting profits from a pattern of criminal activity into their business.
Other charges include conspiracy to steal trade secrets, bank fraud, wire fraud
and obstruction of justice.
“Thefts,
lies and cover-ups,” Assistant US Attorney Meredith Arfa
told jurors. She said Huawei had spent 20 years doing whatever it took to grow
and protect its business, “including committing crimes after crimes”.
Huawei
has denied all wrongdoing. Its lawyers were unable to deliver their closing
arguments on Monday after prosecutors used up the day’s time,
with the defence expected to make its final case on Tuesday.
Jury
deliberations could begin on Wednesday and continue until the jury reaches a
decision.
The
trial started in September, with the prosecution calling 61 witnesses over
nearly seven weeks. Last month, Huawei began presenting its defence, arguing
that its success stemmed from decades of research and development rather than
trade-secret theft or sanctions violations. China has also criticised the
prosecution, portraying the case as an example of US bullying of Chinese
companies.
Prosecutors’
central task was to convince jurors that Huawei had engaged in a systematic
effort to steal trade secrets from leading technology companies. Arfa repeatedly stressed that the alleged thefts were
intended to boost the company’s profits and protect its business, walking
jurors through a detailed and complex body of evidence.
She
cited the case involving T-Mobile’s smartphone-testing robot, known as Tappy. The court was shown a video that prosecutors said
depicted a Huawei employee taking away part of the robot. The employee
subsequently lied about the incident, prosecutors alleged. Arfa
also cited the alleged theft of Cisco source code, among other examples.
Prosecutors
also pointed to what they described as a corporate culture that encouraged
employees to obtain competitors’ confidential information, citing a 2013 memo
offering bonuses to staff who secured such material.
Arfa said Huawei had also attempted to
obstruct justice as the investigation unfolded, including by moving employees
out of the United States. Prosecutors further accused the company of lying to
the media and US Congress.
On
the Iran allegations, prosecutors said Huawei used Skycom,
a Hong Kong-registered company operating in Iran, as a concealed subsidiary to
circumvent US sanctions, while misleading banks, including HSBC, about the
relationship. They alleged that US dollar transactions connected to the Iranian
business were cleared through the American financial system and that Skycom assisted Iran in performing domestic surveillance.
A
key piece of evidence was an admission by Huawei’s chief financial officer,
Meng Wanzhou, made under a 2021 deferred prosecution
agreement that secured her release from house arrest in Canada. Meng acknowledged
that she had misled HSBC about Huawei’s relationship with Skycom,
describing the company as a third party with which Huawei had normal business
cooperation, despite knowing that Huawei controlled it.
Inside
the courtroom, prosecutors displayed a large chart of Huawei’s leadership,
featuring photographs of founder Ren Zhengfei, his
daughter Meng, and other senior executives, as they sought to establish the
involvement of the company’s leadership in the alleged misconduct.
If
convicted, Huawei could face hefty fines and forfeiture of proceeds from the
alleged crimes, potentially amounting to one of the largest corporate penalties
in US history.
The
case attracted global attention in December 2018, when Meng was arrested in
Canada at the request of the United States. She was released in September 2021
after she admitted making false statements to HSBC about Huawei’s business
dealings in Iran. The charges against her were subsequently dismissed. Meng is
not a defendant in the current trial.
Founded
in 1987, Huawei has grown into the world’s largest telecoms equipment maker and
a major smartphone manufacturer. The Shenzhen-based company reported revenue of
US$126 billion in 2025 and employed about 213,000 people worldwide, including
114,000 in research and development.
The
courtroom at the federal courthouse in Brooklyn, in the Eastern District of New
York, was packed on Monday, with an overflow room set up for spectators. Huawei
has assembled an elite legal team, including lawyers from Sidley Austin, Steptoe
and Jenner & Block.