US-Japan Tariff Talks Got
Stuck on Cars and Rice
Negotiations have stalled ahead of next
week’s deadline, with some suggesting Japan misjudged the depth of President
Trump’s frustration over Tokyo’s policies.
Late
last month, Japan’s chief U.S. trade negotiator, Ryosei Akazawa, chatted with
officials gathered at an embassy event in Tokyo. Japan’s top power company had
pledged to buy up to 5.5 million tons of U.S. natural gas each year for two
decades. That was a good start, Mr. Akazawa said, but could it perhaps double
it?
The
remarks from Mr. Akazawa, relayed by two people who spoke on the condition of
anonymity to discuss the private event, highlighted the bind Japan has landed
in days before July 9, when Mr. Trump has indicated his pause on so-called
reciprocal tariffs would expire.
In
months long negotiations with their counterparts in the United States, the
biggest buyer of Japan’s exports, Japanese officials have extended a number of
offers they expected to be well received. They pledged to purchase more
American energy products and defense equipment, and
to help the United States in areas like shipbuilding.
Yet
none of those overtures convinced Mr. Trump to back down on across-the-board
reciprocal tariffs — initially set at 24 percent on Japan — or to remove a
separate 25 percent tariff on cars that has hammered Japanese automakers.
In
recent days, Mr. Trump has emphasized his grievances with Japan over two core
issues. He believes it is unfair that Americans buy Japanese-made cars in
abundance while American cars in Japan are few and far between, and that Japan
imports relatively small amounts of American rice. On Tuesday, he said he
doubted a trade deal was attainable before next week’s deadline.
So
far, the Trump administration has reached preliminary agreements on tariff
reductions with only two countries, Britain and China, highlighting the
difficulties major U.S. trade partners have encountered in negotiations. Still,
some trade experts suggested Japanese negotiators may have miscalculated by
offering concessions peripheral to the issues that have for decades frustrated
Mr. Trump. Mr. Akazawa’s office did not immediately respond to requests for
comment.
The
U.S. administration “welcomes talking about issues like economic security,
natural gas purchases and defense articles,” said
William Chou, the deputy director of the Japan policy center
at the Hudson Institute, a think tank. But for Mr. Trump, he said, “it’s about
what he sees as unfair access and Japan unfairly shutting the U.S. out.”
Mr.
Trump and his trade officials have taken aim at economic barriers in Japan that
they argue impede the sale of American automobiles and agricultural products.
Japan
protects domestic production of rice, its staple grain, with a tariff of about
$2.38 per kilogram on imports beyond a tax-free quota of roughly 770,000 tons.
Last year, nearly half of Japan’s tariff-free rice imports came from the United
States, and Japan has increased purchases from overseas in recent months.
Those
imports apparently weren’t enough for Mr. Trump, whose administration has
called Japanese rice policies “egregious.” In a social media post on Monday,
Mr. Trump wrote that Japan’s reluctance to import more American-grown rice
indicated it was “spoiled” regarding trade with the United States.
Mr.
Trump has also long voiced frustration that only a few thousand American
vehicles sell in Japan each year. In contrast, Japanese automakers exported 1.3
million vehicles to the United States in 2024. But Japanese car companies also
produced millions more at two dozen American manufacturing facilities that
collectively employ more than 100,000 workers.
Mr.
Trump and U.S. trade officials attribute minimal American car sales in Japan to
unfair disadvantages like safety standards that are different than those in the
United States. Others in the industry argue that Japanese consumers prefer
smaller, domestically produced vehicles.
In
Japan, the government could have early on offered the Trump administration
conciliatory measures, like buying more tariff-free American rice to help fill
domestic shortages and allowing cars that pass American standards to drive on
Japanese roads, said Masahiko Hosokawa, a former senior official at Japan’s
trade ministry.
“Trump
has, from the start, made it clear that rice and automobiles are the areas he’s
focused on,” Mr. Hosokawa said. “Japan has been too slow in properly conveying
that it would work on these specific issues,” he added.
Now,
Japanese officials are facing domestic pressures, including a national election
on July 20, that dim the prospects of making concessions on rice imports or
accepting a trade deal that includes the current auto tariffs.
This
means the world’s fourth-largest economy, for now, remains among dozens of
countries confronting the specter of steep tariffs
from its top trading partner with little immediate hope of an agreement.
Japan’s
prime minister, Shigeru Ishiba, has said he is
opposed to signing any deal with the United States that does not roll back car
tariffs. Asked on Tuesday about Mr. Trump’s comments on rice imports, Japan’s
chief cabinet secretary said the country would not consider moves that would
“sacrifice” its agriculture industry.
Given
these sticking points, Tobias Harris, the founder of the advisory firm Japan
Foresight, said the two sides would be unlikely to reach a deal by July 9. The
question, he said, is “whether the two governments can reach some agreement
that extends the suspension of reciprocal tariffs as negotiations continue.”